If a and b are positive integers, is b divisible by a?
(1) 2b/a is an integer.
(2) b^2/a is an integer
We need to find out if 'b' is divisible by 'a' or not. This is a yes-no-type DS question.
Statement 1: \(\frac{2b}{a}\) is an integer.
We suggest translating the statement into equations for easy inference.
We can say that \(\frac{2b}{a} = k\), where 'k' is an integer
So,\(\frac{b}{a} =\frac{k}{2}\)
Now, this is an integer when k is an even number. But we do not know that and hence this statement is not sufficient.
We can eliminate options A, and D.
Statement 2: \(\frac{b^2}{a}\) is an integer.
We again suggest translating the statement into equations for easy inference.
\(\frac{b^2}{a} = k\), where 'k' is an integer
'b' will be divisible by 'a' only when the right side gives us an integer. Now that may or may not be the case.
If k = a, then it will be.
If k = 1, then it will not be.
Hence, this is not sufficient either. We eliminate B as well.
Combine:When we combine we try to see if both yes and no are possible or not.
So if k = 4a (an even number), then we get YES
If k = 1, then we get NO.
Hence, even together they are not sufficient.
Answer: E