Given a , b, c, d > 0
\(\sqrt[]{a} + \sqrt[]{b} = \sqrt[]{c} + \sqrt[]{d} + \sqrt[]{e}\)
QuestionIs b = d + e ?
Statement 1a = c
If a = c, then \(\sqrt[]{a} = \sqrt[]{c}\)
Cancelling, this from the base equation we get,
\(\sqrt[]{b} = \sqrt[]{d} + \sqrt[]{e}\)
Squaring both sides-
\((\sqrt[]{b})^2 = (\sqrt[]{d} + \sqrt[]{e})^2\)
\(b = d + e + 2 * \sqrt[]{de}\)
Hence, we can conclude that
\(b \neq d + e \)
Hence A is sufficient.Statement 2Statement 2 can be solved via observation, however let's take an example to make the thinking process relatively easy
We know that a = d + e
Say d = e = 1
Therefore a = 2
\(\sqrt[]{a} = \sqrt[]{2} \) = 1.414
\(1.414 + \sqrt[]{b} = \sqrt[]{c} + 1 + 1\)
Now if \(\sqrt[]{c}\) = 1.414
\( \sqrt[]{b} = 2\) , hence b = 4 and hence we can conclude that \(b \neq d + e \)
Alternatively,
if d = e = 1 and b = 2, a = 2
\(\sqrt[]{2} + \sqrt[]{2} = \sqrt[]{c} + 1 + 1\)
Hence, when
\(\sqrt[]{c} \approx 0.828 \), then b = d + e.
As we don't know the EXACT value of \(\sqrt[]{c}\), we can't conclude.
Hence the correct answer is A