Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Director
Joined: 01 Apr 2008
Posts: 811
Name: Ronak Amin
Schools: IIM Lucknow (IPMX)  Class of 2014

If y 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of
[#permalink]
Show Tags
Updated on: 11 Sep 2013, 13:01
Question Stats:
50% (01:42) correct 50% (01:45) wrong based on 404 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
If y ≠ 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of the following must be true? I. x = y II. y = 1 III. x and y are prime integers. (A) None (B) I only (C) II only (D) III only (E) I and III Guys, I am sure this might have come earlier, but I am kind of confused about these MUST be true questions. Here, if 3x/y is a prime number greater than 2 then x and y should always be equal so that they can cancel out. We cant have any other factor of 3x/y!!
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
Originally posted by Economist on 30 Mar 2009, 05:02.
Last edited by Bunuel on 11 Sep 2013, 13:01, edited 1 time in total.
Renamed the topic, edited the question and added the OA.



GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1344

Re: DS: Must be true
[#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Mar 2009, 09:38
Economist wrote: If y ≠ 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of the following must be true? Ⅰ. x = y Ⅱ. y = 1 Ⅲ. x and y are prime integers. (A) None (B) Ⅰ only (C) Ⅱonly (D) Ⅲonly (E) Ⅰand Ⅲ
Guys, I am sure this might have come earlier, but I am kind of confused about these MUST be true questions.
Here, if 3x/y is a prime number greater than 2 then x and y should always be equal so that they can cancel out. We cant have any other factor of 3x/y!! There are other possibilities here: 3 might be a factor of y, and might therefore cancel in the fraction, leaving us with a prime that comes from the factors of x. For example, if x = 10, and y = 6, then 3x/y = 5. So we can see that none of I, II, or III need to be true.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Toronto
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com



Senior Manager
Joined: 12 Oct 2008
Posts: 481

Re: DS: Must be true
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 May 2009, 11:35
what about the case x=y? if x=y then x will cancel Y and answer will be 3, which is greater than 2 and it is prime number IanStewart wrote: Economist wrote: If y ≠ 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of the following must be true? Ⅰ. x = y Ⅱ. y = 1 Ⅲ. x and y are prime integers. (A) None (B) Ⅰ only (C) Ⅱonly (D) Ⅲonly (E) Ⅰand Ⅲ
Guys, I am sure this might have come earlier, but I am kind of confused about these MUST be true questions.
Here, if 3x/y is a prime number greater than 2 then x and y should always be equal so that they can cancel out. We cant have any other factor of 3x/y!! There are other possibilities here: 3 might be a factor of y, and might therefore cancel in the fraction, leaving us with a prime that comes from the factors of x. For example, if x = 10, and y = 6, then 3x/y = 5. So we can see that none of I, II, or III need to be true.



GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1344

Re: DS: Must be true
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 May 2009, 11:28
reply2spg wrote: what about the case x=y? if x=y then x will cancel Y and answer will be 3, which is greater than 2 and it is prime number
Yes, it *could* be true that x = y, but the question doesn't ask what could be true; it asks what *must* be true. As I pointed out above, it doesn't need to be true that x = y.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Toronto
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com



SVP
Joined: 06 Sep 2013
Posts: 1801
Concentration: Finance

Re: If y 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of
[#permalink]
Show Tags
11 Sep 2013, 12:51
Tricky question. Took 1.50min to solve it.
But this is what I did.
1st Statement: From first looking at the expression, 'x=y' is the easiest way to have a Prime Integer greater > 2 (3 in this case) from the original question stem. Now we must ask ourselves, is there anyway that this number is a prime number greater than 2 and different from 3? Say for example 5. First look at the denominator, to have 5 as the answer we need to get rid of the 3 so 'y=3', could be an option. Then if 'x = 5, we have that the expression is in fact 5.
So x/y = 5/3 could be an option.
2nd Statement: Does 'y=1" ? We just found out that 'y=3' is an option so this one is out.
3rd Statement: This is a bit more difficult. We need to ask ourselves again, do they both have to be prime integers? Let's start with the denominator, we used 'y=3' in the last example but 'y' could be in fact any multiple of 3, lets say we picked 6. Now, to have '5' (Prime>2) as an answer we could use 10 in the numerator. Since both 'x' and 'y' are 10 and 6 they don't both have to be prime numbers.
So answer is (a) None



Intern
Joined: 28 Apr 2013
Posts: 16
GMAT Date: 08032013
GPA: 3.3
WE: Supply Chain Management (Military & Defense)

Re: If y 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of
[#permalink]
Show Tags
11 Sep 2013, 13:06
jlgdr wrote: Tricky question. Took 1.50min to solve it.
But this is what I did.
1st Statement: From first looking at the expression, 'x=y' is the easiest way to have a Prime Integer greater > 2 (3 in this case) from the original question stem. Now we must ask ourselves, is there anyway that this number is a prime number greater than 2 and different from 3? Say for example 5. First look at the denominator, to have 5 as the answer we need to get rid of the 3 so 'y=3', could be an option. Then if 'x = 5, we have that the expression is in fact 5.
So x/y = 5/3 could be an option.
2nd Statement: Does 'y=1" ? We just found out that 'y=3' is an option so this one is out.
3rd Statement: This is a bit more difficult. We need to ask ourselves again, do they both have to be prime integers? Let's start with the denominator, we used 'y=3' in the last example but 'y' could be in fact any multiple of 3, lets say we picked 6. Now, to have '5' (Prime>2) as an answer we could use 10 in the numerator. Since both 'x' and 'y' are 10 and 6 they don't both have to be prime numbers.
So answer is (a) None The only issue with your response is the prompt explicitly says that y≠3



SVP
Joined: 06 Sep 2013
Posts: 1801
Concentration: Finance

Re: If y 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of
[#permalink]
Show Tags
11 Sep 2013, 13:36
Nwsmith11 wrote: jlgdr wrote: Tricky question. Took 1.50min to solve it.
But this is what I did.
1st Statement: From first looking at the expression, 'x=y' is the easiest way to have a Prime Integer greater > 2 (3 in this case) from the original question stem. Now we must ask ourselves, is there anyway that this number is a prime number greater than 2 and different from 3? Say for example 5. First look at the denominator, to have 5 as the answer we need to get rid of the 3 so 'y=3', could be an option. Then if 'x = 5, we have that the expression is in fact 5.
So x/y = 5/3 could be an option.
2nd Statement: Does 'y=1" ? We just found out that 'y=3' is an option so this one is out.
3rd Statement: This is a bit more difficult. We need to ask ourselves again, do they both have to be prime integers? Let's start with the denominator, we used 'y=3' in the last example but 'y' could be in fact any multiple of 3, lets say we picked 6. Now, to have '5' (Prime>2) as an answer we could use 10 in the numerator. Since both 'x' and 'y' are 10 and 6 they don't both have to be prime numbers.
So answer is (a) None The only issue with your response is the prompt explicitly says that y≠3 You are right appologies, my bad. So we could just use x=10 and y=6 for all the Statements and there we go.



Director
Joined: 03 Feb 2013
Posts: 887
Location: India
Concentration: Operations, Strategy
GPA: 3.88
WE: Engineering (Computer Software)

Re: If y 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Jul 2014, 07:25
Economist wrote: If y ≠ 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of the following must be true?
I. x = y II. y = 1 III. x and y are prime integers.
(A) None (B) I only (C) II only (D) III only (E) I and III
Guys, I am sure this might have come earlier, but I am kind of confused about these MUST be true questions.
Here, if 3x/y is a prime number greater than 2 then x and y should always be equal so that they can cancel out. We cant have any other factor of 3x/y!! Must be true should hold in all the cases3x/y can be = 3 in this case, Option A) and Option B) comes. It doesn't satisfy Option C) as x= y = 1 is a possibility If 3x/y = 5, in this case, Option A) and Option B) goes out of the way and it satisfies option C) Hence None.
_________________
Thanks, Kinjal My Debrief : http://gmatclub.com/forum/hardworknevergetsunrewardedforever189267.html#p1449379 My Application Experience : http://gmatclub.com/forum/hardworknevergetsunrewardedforever18926740.html#p1516961 Linkedin : https://www.linkedin.com/in/kinjaldas/
Please click on Kudos, if you think the post is helpful



Manager
Joined: 20 Apr 2018
Posts: 169
Concentration: Technology, Nonprofit
WE: Analyst (NonProfit and Government)

Re: If y 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of
[#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Jun 2018, 03:51
I think the best way to go is to try to break the statements. I tried taking irrational nos as x and y, and made 3x/y prime For example: x = 7*sqrt(3); y = 3*sqrt(3), 3x/y = 7.
Answer: A



Senior Manager
Joined: 04 Aug 2010
Posts: 277
Schools: Dartmouth College

Re: If y 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of
[#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Jun 2018, 05:02
Economist wrote: If y ≠ 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of the following must be true?
I. x = y II. y = 1 III. x and y are prime integers.
(A) None (B) I only (C) II only (D) III only (E) I and III Make a list of options for \(\frac{3x}{y}\) and solve for x: \(\frac{3x}{y}\) = 3, 5, 7, 11... 3x = 3y, 5y, 7y, 11y... x = y, \(\frac{5y}{3}\), \(\frac{7y}{3}\), \(\frac{11y}{3}\)... If \(x = \frac{5y}{3}\), then it's possible that \(y=4\) and that \(x=\frac{20}{3}\), with the result that I, II, and III are all NOT true.
_________________
GMAT and GRE Tutor Over 1800 followers Click here to learn more GMATGuruNY@gmail.com New York, NY If you find one of my posts helpful, please take a moment to click on the "Kudos" icon. Available for tutoring in NYC and longdistance. For more information, please email me at GMATGuruNY@gmail.com.




Re: If y 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of &nbs
[#permalink]
26 Jun 2018, 05:02






