RonnieRon
Jon - I am a bit surprised when you say Top 10 are actually dream schools....Considering that he is Indian applicant, but with startup background (immaterial of the size and scope - NGO or not, mm$ or not), I though he would be a very good shot for Yale, Col, LBS etc...
I am intrigued to know why you thought so - because it will definitely help all of us to know this better what Adcoms really want, apart from really deep pockets.
a simple query being your comment - "in terms of the size of the company, for the moment, I don't think they will be aaaall that impressed yet" - does that mean the other applicants, in the entrepreneur category are Million$ streamers. Adding to it, will only IIT grads get any notice with a top 10? How is that mix, also considering he wants to continue with Water segment post MBA....
Thanks for your reply.
+1 if your like my comments
Hey Ronny,
You have good points, and I'll try and answer all of them. But first of all, let me give my little caveat that this evaluation is based on two forum posts, and normally before we figure out where a candidate should apply we would dig a wee bit deeper.
So first of all, the strength of a startup will impress based on its concrete results or growth. It's true, I'd say that a somewhat successful startup is still better than your average IT job. About that there is no doubt, but still, they will look at if you have gotten funding, how many people you have led, how much growth there has been, what achievements you personally have and what achievements the company has. And right now, it seems that Arjun is at the beginning of his enterprise, and it is of yet a bit hard to tell. Which means that the Adcom will have to take a risk on him. And they might - if his story is awesome. Especially since his startup will help people.
Secondly, as you probably know, the Indian applicant pool is huge and tough. And a 750 is awesome as a GMAT, but I am seeing (like the schools are seeing) dozens and dozens of Indian candidates with such great scores, so nobody will get in on GMAT alone. And the truth is that the majority of Indian candidates in top 10 schools come from IIT. That's not to say that it's impossible for a non-IIT to get in, buuuuut it is harder, and if the GPA is not awesome (8 or above in most cases) then it's even harder.
And those are the main things that make me think that 1-10 would be dream schools, and 10-20 competitive. And that's also why I think that the most successful application will ride on the story of what he wants to do,
I hope this makes sense,
And if you have any thoughts/questions/doubts, drop a line,
Best,
JF