Events & Promotions
|
|
GMAT Club Daily Prep
Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.
Customized
for You
Track
Your Progress
Practice
Pays
Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.
Nov 2007:30 AM PST
-08:30 AM PST
Learn what truly sets the UC Riverside MBA apart and how it helps in your professional growth
Nov 2211:00 AM IST
-01:00 PM IST
Do RC/MSR passages scare you? e-GMAT is conducting a masterclass to help you learn – Learn effective reading strategies Tackle difficult RC & MSR with confidence Excel in timed test environment- Nov 23
11:00 AM IST
-01:00 PM IST
Attend this free GMAT Algebra Webinar and learn how to master the most challenging Inequalities and Absolute Value problems with ease. 
Nov 2510:00 AM EST
-11:00 AM EST
Prefer video-based learning? The Target Test Prep OnDemand course is a one-of-a-kind video masterclass featuring 400 hours of lecture-style teaching by Scott Woodbury-Stewart, founder of Target Test Prep and one of the most accomplished GMAT instructors.
16 Sep 2014, 01:47
Kudos
Bookmarks
D
Be sure to select an answer first to save it in the Error Log before revealing the correct answer (OA)!
Difficulty:
25%
(medium)
Question Stats:
77% (02:02) correct
23%
(02:21)
wrong
based on 66
sessions
History
Date
Time
Result
Not Attempted Yet
Of the 60 participants in a clinical trial, 30 participants were considered to be in the experimental group, and were administered a large dose of an experimental painkiller called nexaphedrinol, while the 30 remaining participants were considered to be in the control group, and were administered the same dose of a placebo. Afterward, participants in the experimental group exhibited fine motor skills that were more diminished than those of the control group. The observed detrimental effects on fine motor skills were attributed to a compound in nexaphedrinol called phedrine, which temporarily damages nerve endings.
Which of the following, if true, would best support the conclusion that a certain compound in the painkiller was responsible for the observed results?
A. Nexaphedrinol has been found to be the most effective painkiller available in a variety of preceding experiments that utilized similar methodologies.
B. Phedrine is a relatively ubiquitous compound found in a variety of medicines, some of which may have been taken by the participants in the experiment.
C. The placebo administered to the participants in the experiment did not contain phedrine but may have contained a compound with similar effects on nerve endings.
D. All the participants in the experiment were found to have had comparable fine motor skills prior to the administration of the nexaphedrinol or the placebo.
E. Most customers suffering from chronic pain have indicated that they would be willing to suffer a decrease in fine motor skills in exchange for an effective painkiller.
Which of the following, if true, would best support the conclusion that a certain compound in the painkiller was responsible for the observed results?
A. Nexaphedrinol has been found to be the most effective painkiller available in a variety of preceding experiments that utilized similar methodologies.
B. Phedrine is a relatively ubiquitous compound found in a variety of medicines, some of which may have been taken by the participants in the experiment.
C. The placebo administered to the participants in the experiment did not contain phedrine but may have contained a compound with similar effects on nerve endings.
D. All the participants in the experiment were found to have had comparable fine motor skills prior to the administration of the nexaphedrinol or the placebo.
E. Most customers suffering from chronic pain have indicated that they would be willing to suffer a decrease in fine motor skills in exchange for an effective painkiller.
16 Sep 2014, 01:47
Kudos
Bookmarks
Official Solution:
Of the 60 participants in a clinical trial, 30 participants were considered to be in the experimental group, and were administered a large dose of an experimental painkiller called nexaphedrinol, while the 30 remaining participants were considered to be in the control group, and were administered the same dose of a placebo. Afterward, participants in the experimental group exhibited fine motor skills that were more diminished than those of the control group. The observed detrimental effects on fine motor skills were attributed to a compound in nexaphedrinol called phedrine, which temporarily damages nerve endings.
Which of the following, if true, would best support the conclusion that a certain compound in the painkiller was responsible for the observed results?
A. Nexaphedrinol has been found to be the most effective painkiller available in a variety of preceding experiments that utilized similar methodologies.
B. Phedrine is a relatively ubiquitous compound found in a variety of medicines, some of which may have been taken by the participants in the experiment.
C. The placebo administered to the participants in the experiment did not contain phedrine but may have contained a compound with similar effects on nerve endings.
D. All the participants in the experiment were found to have had comparable fine motor skills prior to the administration of the nexaphedrinol or the placebo.
E. Most customers suffering from chronic pain have indicated that they would be willing to suffer a decrease in fine motor skills in exchange for an effective painkiller.
We're told that in a clinical trial 30 people in an experimental group were given a painkiller and 30 people in a control group were given a placebo. The people in the experimental group had poorer fine motor skills when the experiment was over than the people in the control group.
The author concludes that something in the painkiller causes the lack of fine motor skills. The question asks us to support this argument. Therefore, we're looking for an answer choice that proves that the painkiller, not some other factor, is the cause of the poor fine motor skills.
Choice D is correct. Choice D tells us that before the experiment began, all participants in the trial had comparable motor skills. This means that after the experiment, none of the participants had bad motor skills simply due to a preexisting lack of coordination or a muscular disorder. It must have been the drug that they took--the only thing that happened between the beginning and the end of the experiment. Choice D strengthens the argument and is therefore correct.
Choice A states that nexaphedrinol has been found to be an effective painkiller. In fact, this is not at all the issue in this argument. The argument states that the painkiller has a detrimental effect on fine motor skills; the effectiveness of the drug is not at issue.
Choice B states that phedrine (the compound that is said to be responsible for the loss of fine motor skills) is found in other medicines, and this choice implies that the control group may have been tainted by it. This is a serious accusation; however, we are looking for a strengthener of the claim that the phedrine in the painkiller caused the loss of fine motor skills. If the experiment were tainted, and people in the control group did not exhibit this symptom to the same extent, that would weaken the argument, not strengthen it.
Choice C states that the placebo may have contained a compound with an effect similar to phedrine's (temporary damage of nerve endings). This choice weakens the conclusion, by implying that the control group may have been affected in the same way, chemically, as the experimental group, without similar results on nerve endings.
Choice E implies that customers might be willing to suffer a loss of fine motor skills in order to relieve pain. This is besides the point; the claim that the nexaphedrinol caused the loss of fine motor damage in the first place must still be strengthened. The conclusion of this argument has nothing to do with the willingness of customers to take the painkiller.
Answer: D
Of the 60 participants in a clinical trial, 30 participants were considered to be in the experimental group, and were administered a large dose of an experimental painkiller called nexaphedrinol, while the 30 remaining participants were considered to be in the control group, and were administered the same dose of a placebo. Afterward, participants in the experimental group exhibited fine motor skills that were more diminished than those of the control group. The observed detrimental effects on fine motor skills were attributed to a compound in nexaphedrinol called phedrine, which temporarily damages nerve endings.
Which of the following, if true, would best support the conclusion that a certain compound in the painkiller was responsible for the observed results?
A. Nexaphedrinol has been found to be the most effective painkiller available in a variety of preceding experiments that utilized similar methodologies.
B. Phedrine is a relatively ubiquitous compound found in a variety of medicines, some of which may have been taken by the participants in the experiment.
C. The placebo administered to the participants in the experiment did not contain phedrine but may have contained a compound with similar effects on nerve endings.
D. All the participants in the experiment were found to have had comparable fine motor skills prior to the administration of the nexaphedrinol or the placebo.
E. Most customers suffering from chronic pain have indicated that they would be willing to suffer a decrease in fine motor skills in exchange for an effective painkiller.
We're told that in a clinical trial 30 people in an experimental group were given a painkiller and 30 people in a control group were given a placebo. The people in the experimental group had poorer fine motor skills when the experiment was over than the people in the control group.
The author concludes that something in the painkiller causes the lack of fine motor skills. The question asks us to support this argument. Therefore, we're looking for an answer choice that proves that the painkiller, not some other factor, is the cause of the poor fine motor skills.
Choice D is correct. Choice D tells us that before the experiment began, all participants in the trial had comparable motor skills. This means that after the experiment, none of the participants had bad motor skills simply due to a preexisting lack of coordination or a muscular disorder. It must have been the drug that they took--the only thing that happened between the beginning and the end of the experiment. Choice D strengthens the argument and is therefore correct.
Choice A states that nexaphedrinol has been found to be an effective painkiller. In fact, this is not at all the issue in this argument. The argument states that the painkiller has a detrimental effect on fine motor skills; the effectiveness of the drug is not at issue.
Choice B states that phedrine (the compound that is said to be responsible for the loss of fine motor skills) is found in other medicines, and this choice implies that the control group may have been tainted by it. This is a serious accusation; however, we are looking for a strengthener of the claim that the phedrine in the painkiller caused the loss of fine motor skills. If the experiment were tainted, and people in the control group did not exhibit this symptom to the same extent, that would weaken the argument, not strengthen it.
Choice C states that the placebo may have contained a compound with an effect similar to phedrine's (temporary damage of nerve endings). This choice weakens the conclusion, by implying that the control group may have been affected in the same way, chemically, as the experimental group, without similar results on nerve endings.
Choice E implies that customers might be willing to suffer a loss of fine motor skills in order to relieve pain. This is besides the point; the claim that the nexaphedrinol caused the loss of fine motor damage in the first place must still be strengthened. The conclusion of this argument has nothing to do with the willingness of customers to take the painkiller.
Answer: D
Moderator:
