The users of the new Dell Laptop claim that it is much more better, or

Question

The users of the new Dell Laptop claim that it  is much more better, or at least as better, as any  of the other laptops currently available in the market.

(A) is much more better, or at least as better, as any
(B) is much better, or at least as better, as any
(C) is much better, or at least as better, than any
(D) is much better than any
(E) is more better than any

KyleWiddison · Accepted Answer

Good explanation here. I would only add that for C, the construction "as better as" would have to be "as good as". Really, if you wanted to fix C it would need to go as follows: is much better than, or at least as good as, any

KW

Zarrolou · Answer

We can eliminate A and E because they use "more better".
"is much better, (...), as any" is wrong, the correct idiom is better than: out B.
We have left C and D. My pick is D. In C ",or at least as better," should have a "as" to complete the idiom "as better as".
Waiting for OA...

daagh · Answer

The simple way to solve this thread:The expression ‘as better as’ is awful and all those choices A, B and C that say that, befit to be kicked from a mile away. 
The second point is that we are talking about quality, which is an abstract singular noun. So we cannot use more better. 
So, we can be happy with D

blueseas · Answer

hi daagh ,

my question is that whether in option D dont you think meaning is changed.
 as per my understanding there is comparison between 2 things in which 1 thing is either much better or of the same quality of the other,whereas in the correct answer it is saying only much better.
please explain where i am wrong.

regards
SKM

daagh · Answer

@Shilesh
Yes Shlesh; You are indeed right in re: the change of meaning. The text is distinctly changed from the OA. OA is only half the way jumping the well. But (to give a lame excuse), the intention is so badly expressed, that one likes to ignore it and go wih D as a matter of something that is better than nothing.

KyleWiddison · Answer

A quick note on meaning ( as some have been hesitant to change the meaning of the original on this problem). Your job is to preserve the meaning of the original sentence, unless the meaning is flawed - then you have to fix the meaning flaws of the original sentence.

KW

KW

blueseas · Answer

hi KyleWiddison,

it means in this question the meaning is flawed,...if it is so please elaborate what is the actual meaning of the sentence.

thanks

SKM

KyleWiddison · Answer

SKM-

Are you asking about the actual intended meaning (revealed in the correct answer) or the flawed meaning of the original?

KW

blueseas · Answer

Hi ,

if possible do explain both the flawed and intended meaning....and suggest where i am going wrong...

regards

SKM

KyleWiddison · Answer

The correct meaning states that users of the new Dell laptop find it to be much better than the competition. Very standard, clear comparison here. The flawed meaning incorrectly tries to combine a few of they standard comparisons. In this 'family' of comparisons you would have 'worse than', 'as good as', and 'better than'. These three options are mutually exclusive - you are either worse than, or as good as, or better than. The original tries to combine better than with as good as, something you shouldn't do, and the original even fails in this faulty combination by stating 'as better (as)'.

There could be a case when you could combine 2 of the comparisons - This home-made ice cream is as good as, if not better than, expensive store bought ice cream. In this case, the author isn't sure which of the two comparisons to choose because either could be correct. In the case of our 'Dell' sentence, however, the sentence states that the Dell computer is clearly 'much better' than any other, so there is not logical reason to include both comparisons.

Does that help?

KW

blueseas · Answer

HI ,

thanks for the explanation...now it seems clear..but one more question will this concept is going to hold for all question of this type....?

well great explanation kyle.

regards

SKM

KyleWiddison · Answer

Yes, this logic will apply to other comparison questions where you are dealing with worse than/as good as/better than (also less than/as much as/more than).

KW

Bunuel · Answer

Official Explanation

Answer: D

(A)  More better  is a redundant phrase. Also  better  needs to be followed by  than .

(B)  Much better  needs to be followed by  than , it cannot be much better  as .

(C)  As better  needs to be followed by  as  and not by  than .

(D) The correct answer.

(E)  More better  is a redundant phrase.

RICHA1189 · Answer

(D) is much better than any

Abstract noun - much

Use of Better as is wrong .

The users of the new Dell Laptop claim that it is much more better, or

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

The users of the new Dell Laptop claim that it is much more better, or

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards