Ranking Consulting Schools based on LinkedIn members

Question

This is what popped up when I did a quick filter on the big 3 consulting firms: Bain, McKinsey, and BCG. Here is how schools stack up against each other based off of sheer numbers of current (interns) and former (full-time consultants) students from each program currently with MBB:

1. HBS - 909
2. Wharton - 710
3. Kellogg - 584
4. Columbia - 369
5. Chicago - 307
6. Stanford - 304
7. MIT - 301
8. Michigan - 221
9. Tuck - 162
10. NYU - 133
11. Haas - 122
12. Duke - 120
13. Darden - 91
14. UCLA - 79
15. Cornell - 55
16. Yale - 43

Of course not all schools are the same size so if you wanted a more accurate ranking you would need to adjust each number based on each programs class size, but I will let you do that math 8-)

asimov · Answer

I think this is a fair indicator. As suggested, things like class size, and school history also plays a part. For example, Fuqua (#12 on your list) only started in 1970 with a class size of 20.

I think a better indicator of current situation is to look at the latest employment report. Even that is misleading, since some school's student population is less consulting focused.

IMO, if your school is in the core school for the company you are recruiting for, you should be fine.

Also, GMATClub discussions focus a lot on consulting and ibanking; however, consulting and ibanking isn't the goal for every students. I find that many of my classmates actually shy away from consulting and ibanking in favor of management and marketing for the work/life balance. In fact, the General Management Club and Marketing Club are two of the largest and best-run clubs here at Fuqua.

Izvos · Answer

Very cool approach and in general it shows real situation. Look at Stanford

asimov · Answer

I bet if Stanford had a class size like the schools above it, it would be right up there.

riverripper · Answer

I highly doubt there are many consultants included in those numbers graduated pre-1980. Those numbers are probably very heavily weighted to recent grads since very few people stay at the big firms for more than several years.

Alchemist1320 · Answer

interesting thread

mreevit · Answer

I've taken the same numbers and divided by class size to control for that factor. There are a few others that cannot be controlled for - career goals, interests, location preferences, etc.

School MBB #/AVG Class Size/Ratio
1) HBS 909 900 101%
2) Wharton 710 817 87%
3) Kellogg 584 700 83%
4) Stanford 304 370 82%
5) MIT 301 392 77%
6) Tuck 162 240 68%
7) Booth 307 580 53%
8) HAAS 122 245 50%
9) Michigan 221 488 45%
10) NYU 133 392 34%
11) Columbia 369 1278 29%
12) Duke 120 440 27%
13) Darden 91 339 27%
14) UCLA 79 360 22%
15) Cornell 55 278 20%
16) Yale 43 230 19%

MBAbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club MBAbot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

Ranking Consulting Schools based on LinkedIn members

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia