Hello sburtonhome, thanks for your question.
I typically advise clients: your GMAT score opens the door (the high the score dictates how wide open the door), but it is certainly your experience that gets you through that door. So, a big part of the equation depends on your GMAT, which is currently unknown (practice tests have been known to be wrong in both directions, in my experience).
That said, I think you have a unique background – I would use the essays to differentiate yourself. After all, the schools get plenty of applications from impeccably educated consultants from the top firms, right? Programs do want a diverse class. Don’t think of your non-traditional history as a detriment; consider it a potential leg up. Of course, the onus is on you to speak to “moments” when you truly led: influenced individuals and organizations, drove results, took initiative.
School choice is such a personal decision, and I would be doing you a disservice if I told you where to apply. Research those top 20 programs, speak to/email students and alumni. Get a sense of the ethos and culture of a place. If you lean toward smaller and more intimate settings, maybe HBS, Wharton, CBS are not for you! There are plenty of fantastic programs – definitely make sure you apply to the ones you genuinely feel a fit with.
Depending on your score, I would think Tuck, Darden, and Fuqua are within reach. You might add Ross to that list.
I hope this helps.
Best of luck,
Brian
Brian, thank you for your reply. It is very helpful. I have added Ross to my list.