In the 1870s, small groups of immigrants, many from Eastern

Question

In the 1870s, small groups of immigrants, many from Eastern Europe, formed the earliest anarchist parties in the United States, but most Americans  became concerned about the movement only after when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred in 1886. 
 
A) became concerned about the movement only after when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred in 1886
B) became concerned about the movement only after 1886, when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred
C) became concerned about the movement only after the occurrence of the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886
D) developed concerns about the movement only after the time of the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886
E) developed concern about the movement only after there being the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886

I am little bit skeptical about the OA...

umeshpatil · Accepted Answer

Hi Jackouille, 
Option B make the second part of sentence as below.
  Americans became concerned about the movement  only after 1886, when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred

Don't you think the line seems bit awkward? Action in the sentence has happened after 1886 as well as after Riot. Both are connected by comma. When two sentences are connected by when (as conjunction), we don't use comma between them.

ketanth · Answer

In the 1870s, small groups of immigrants, many from Eastern Europe, formed the earliest anarchist parties in the United States, but most Americans became concerned about the movement only after when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred in 1886.

A) became concerned about the movement only after when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred in 1886. "after when" is wrong. 
B) became concerned about the movement only after 1886, when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred. Grammatically its correct. But the meaning is changing. It seems they became more concerned because of the year and not because of the riot. 
C) became concerned about the movement only after the occurrence of the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886.  Correct . Grammatically and meaning wise
D) developed concerns about the movement only after the time of the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886 - Changes meaning. Seems to indicate many concerns but in reality we are just told that they became concerned. 
E) developed concern about the movement only after there being the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886. - "there being" is unnecessary.

umeshpatil · Answer

IMO: C

In the 1870s, small groups of immigrants, many from Eastern Europe, formed the earliest anarchist parties in the United States, but most Americans  became concerned about the movement only after when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred in 1886. 
 
A) became concerned about the movement only  after when  the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred in 1886
B) became concerned about the movement only  after 1886, when  the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred
C) became concerned about the movement  only after the occurrence of  the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886
D) developed concerns about the movement only  after the time of  the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886
E) developed concern about the movement only  after there being  the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886

rohitgupta86 · Answer

I second that..
As per the Manhattan Sentence Correction guide..
sentences with 'being' should be generally avoided in GMAT..
I had confusion between C and E...
the 'being' factor helped me to eliminate E...hence, picked C

umeshpatil · Answer

@rohitgupta86, thanks for showing me evil spirit of 'being'

Its good idea to eliminate the option. I chose C because, Preposition after should be followed by an event that indicates specific point of time i.e. Occurrence. Its awkward to read after there being..riot

Darmody · Answer

yes OA is C.

Can somebody explain me what is exactly wrong with B ? I really don't see

skiingforthewknds · Answer

umeshpatil,

I am not really seeing it either, are you indicating that the awkwardness occurs that the people only became concerned after the year 1886, which is somewhat bizarre to refer to an event in the scope of an entire year? I feel that the sentence following correctly modifies the year telling the reader what happened that year that made people become concerned with the movement.

Any clarification helps.

Thanks.

Darmody · Answer

thx for your answer but I still don't get the point here. "when the bloody Haymarket occured" modifies the year 1886 so it seems compeltely legit to me. Especially, I don't see why C would correct the problem.

BangOn · Answer

The real problem is the intent. If you see the main sentence(A) it says that .............. the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred in 1886 and after that the movement.
B says............... only after 1886, when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred
This gives meaning that ...........movement gets attention when the bloody riot occurred not the original meaning after riot.

Dinesh2Apr · Answer

The original sentence states that Americans developed concerns about the movement only after the Riot of 1886. The sentence does not exactly state the year when these concerns developed, it only provides information on the year when the riot occurred

B) became concerned about the movement only after 1886, when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred :- this option although grammatically correct changes the meaning of the original sentence, in addition to telling when the riots occurred it also tells you when American`s developed concerns

C) became concerned about the movement only after the occurrence of the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886 :- this option corrects the meaning change in option B, by shifting the preposition in 1886 after occurrence to correctly modify only the occurrence of riots

sanjoo · Answer

I chose B..

C luks good too.. bt will any one explain y B is wrong here??

sivasanjeev · Answer

The riot actually occurred in 1886. But according to B, the riot occurred (at an unspecified time) after 1886.

pretzel · Answer

I chose B but on second thought, C seems more reasonable.

B should be "when the bloody Haymarket Riot   had   occurred"

Celestial09 · Answer

Experts Chetan / veritable / egmat/ mgmat / magoosh plz help me in understanding why option B is incorrect and why option C is correct. 
Thanks

https://gmatclub.com/static/posted_from.png     Posted from    GMAT ToolKit

HSGMAT16 · Answer

While I am not an expert but sharing my thought process....

B) became concerned about the movement only after 1886, when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred.  This option seems to imply that the people became concerned only after the year 1886. Meaning wise - at any time in the year 1887 or later. "when....occurred" is providing additional details about a particular event in the year 1886. 
C) became concerned about the movement only after the occurrence of the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886.  In this option, the people became concerned after the occurrence of the riots that happened in 1886. This seems more logical to me - the event or occurrence of the riots is the time marker after which people became concerned.

Divyadisha · Answer

The meaning of the sentence is that Americans became concerned about some movements after some riots, and there were riots happened to in 1886.

Out of B and C. C is the right option for below reasons:-

B) became concerned about the movement only after 1886, when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred. 
 This sentence says that movement occurred after 1886 and this is the time when some riots occurred. If we notice, more importance is given to the 'time' here and not to the 'riots'

C) became concerned about the movement only after the occurrence of the bloody Haymarket Riot in 1886.
 C depicts the meaning that we are looking for. It says that Americans became concerned after the riots, which happened to occur in 1886.

Temurkhon · Answer

Sentence says "...formed the earliest anarchist parties in the United States...", so emphasis is made to time.

I think B is logical choice

Camach700 · Answer

Temurkhon

I think none of the previous explanations actually gets the point here..

IMO the reason why option B is incorrect is that in the sentence " Most Americans became concerned about the movement only after 1886, when the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred " the word  when  modifies the year 1886, which is grammatically incorrect.

When can be an adverb, conjunction, pronoun, and noun. "I will move my car when ready." (adverb), "Please move you car when you are asked to do so." (conjunction), "I need to move the car by when?" (pronoun), and in rarer form, "What does the 'when' mean in your notice, about moving the car when it's necessary?" (noun)

Accordingly, " when " should be used in place of " 1886 ", and should not modify it. If we wanted to correctly modify the year "1886" we should say something like:

Most Americans became concerned about the movement only after 1886,  in which year  the bloody Haymarket Riot occurred

Hope it helps.

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

In the 1870s, small groups of immigrants, many from Eastern

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

In the 1870s, small groups of immigrants, many from Eastern

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards