HWPO
Theoretically, shouldn't the probability be 20/80 - 1/4 ?
Person B chooses a book only AFTER person A does. So if person A is to first choose a poetry and there are currently 80 books, wouldn't the probability simply be 1/4?
You are 100% correct about the physical timeline. When Person A walked up to that shelf, they absolutely had 80 books in front of them. If you were standing next to Person A at that exact moment, the probability of them picking a poetry book was exactly 20/80.
The confusion comes from the difference between
the physical timeline of events and
our timeline of acquiring information. Probability isn't just a measure of what physically happened; it's a measure of our
uncertainty based on what we currently know.
Here is a thought experiment to show why future information changes our math about the past.
The Closed Bag Analogy
Imagine the exact same scenario, but we add a small detail:
- Person A walks up to the 80 books, closes their eyes, picks one, and puts it in an opaque, sealed bag.
- Person B walks up, picks a book, and immediately shows it to us. It is The Great Gatsby (a novel).
- Now, we are standing around Person A's sealed bag, trying to calculate the odds of what is inside it.
Could
The Great Gatsby be in Person A's bag?
No. Because Person B is physically holding it, we know with 100% certainty that Person A did not pick it.
Even though Person A
could have picked
The Great Gatsby at the exact moment they were standing at the shelf, our new information completely eliminates that specific book from the realm of possibility.
Shrinking the Universe of Possibilities
When you are asked "What is the probability that Person A chose a poetry book,
given that Person B chose a novel?", you are being asked to calculate probability in a universe where Person B's action has already been locked in as a fact.
- Before B's choice: There are 80 possible books in A's bag. 20 are poetry. (Probability = 20/80).
- After B's choice: We look at the novel B is holding. We can now cross that specific novel off the list of "books that might be in A's bag." There are now only 79 possible books that could be in A's bag. All 20 poetry books are still on that list of possibilities. (Probability = 20/79).