Many political economists believe that the soundest indicator of the

Question

Many political economists believe that the soundest
indicator of the economic health of a nation is the
nation’s gross national product (GNP) per capita—a
figure reached by dividing the total value of the goods
 (5)  produced yearly in a nation by its population and taken
to be a measure of the welfare of the nation’s residents.
But there are many factors affecting residents’ welfare
that are not captured by per capita GNP; human
indicators, while sometimes more difficult to calculate
 (10)  or document, provide sounder measures of a nation’s
progress than does the indicator championed by these
economists. These human indicators include nutrition
and life expectancy; birth weight and level of infant
mortality; ratio of population level to availability of
 (15)  resources; employment opportunities; and the ability
of governments to provide services such as education,
clean water, medicine, public transportation, and mass
communication for their residents.

The economists defend their use of per capita GNP
 (20)  as the sole measure of a nation’s economic health by
claiming that improvements in per capita GNP
eventually stimulate improvements in human
indicators. But, in actuality, this often fails to occur.
Even in nations where economic stimulation has
 (25)  brought about substantial improvements in per capita
GNP, economic health as measured by human
indicators does not always reach a level commensurate
with the per capita GNP. Nations that have achieved a
relatively high per capita GNP, for example, sometimes
 (30)  experience levels of infant survival, literacy, nutrition,
and life expectancy no greater than levels in nations
where per capita GNP is relatively low. In addition,
because per capita GNP is an averaged figure, it often
presents a distorted picture of the wealth of a nation;
 (35)  for example, in a relatively sparsely populated nation
where a small percentage of residents receives most of
the economic benefits of production while the majority
receives very little benefit, per capita GNP may
nevertheless be high. The welfare of a nation’s
 (40)  residents is a matter not merely of total economic
benefit, but also of the distribution of economic
benefits across the entire society. Measuring a nation’s
economic health only by total wealth frequently
obscures a lack of distribution of wealth across the
 (45)  society as a whole.

In light of the potential for such imbalances in
distribution of economic benefits, some nations have
begun to realize that their domestic economic efforts
are better directed away from attempting to raise per
 (50)  capita GNP and instead toward ensuring that the
conditions measured by human indicators are salutary.
They recognize that unless a shift in focus away from
using material wealth as the sole indicator of economic
success is effected, the well-being of the nation may be
 (55)  endangered, and that nations that do well according
to human indicators may thrive even if their per capita
GNP remains stable or lags behind that of other
nations.    1 
 1. Which one of the following titles most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

(A) “The Shifting Meaning of Per Capita GNP: A Historical Perspective”
(B) “A Defense of Per Capita GNP: An Economist’s Rejoinder”
(C) “The Preferability of Human Indicators as Measures of National Economic Health”
(D) “Total Wealth vs. Distribution of Wealth as a Measure of Economic Health”
(E) “A New Method of Calculating Per Capita GNP to Measure National Economic Health”

2 
 2. The term “welfare” is used in the first paragraph to refer most specifically to which one of the following?

(A) the overall quality of life for individuals in a nation
(B) the services provided to individuals by a government
(C) the material wealth owned by individuals in a nation
(D) the extent to which the distribution of wealth among individuals in a nation is balanced
(E) government efforts to redistribute wealth across society as a whole

3 
 3. The passage provides specific information about each of the following EXCEPT:

(A) how per capita GNP is calculated
(B) what many political economists believe to be an accurate measure of a nation’s economic health
(C) how nations with a relatively low per capita GNP can sometimes be economically healthier than nations whose per capita GNP is higher
(D) why human indicators may not provide the same picture of a nation’s economic health that per capita GNP does
(E) how nations can adjust their domestic economic efforts to bring about substantial improvements in per capita GNP

4 
 4. Which one of the following scenarios, if true, would most clearly be a counterexample to the views expressed in the last paragraph of the passage?

(A) The decision by a nation with a low level of economic health as measured by human indicators to focus on increasing the levels of human indicators results in slower growth in its per capita GNP.
(B) The decision by a nation with a low level of economic health as measured by human indicators to focus on increasing domestic production of goods results in significant improvements in the levels of human indicators.
(C) The decision by a nation with a low level of economic health as measured by human indicators to focus on increasing the levels of human indicators results in increased growth in per capita GNP.
(D) The decision by a nation with a low per capita GNP to focus on improving its level of economic health as measured by human indicators fails to bring about an increase in per capita GNP.
(E) The decision by a nation with a low per capita GNP to focus on increasing domestic production of goods fails to improve its economic health as measured by human indicators.

5 
 5. The primary function of the last paragraph of the passage is to

(A) offer a synthesis of the opposing positions outlined in the first two paragraphs
(B) expose the inadequacies of both positions outlined in the first two paragraphs
(C) summarize the argument made in the first two paragraphs
(D) correct a weakness in the political economists’ position as outlined in the second paragraph
(E) suggest policy implications of the argument made in the first two paragraphs

6 
 6. Based on the passage, the political economists discussed in the passage would be most likely to agree with which one of the following statements?

(A) A change in a nation’s per capita GNP predicts a similar future change in the state of human indicators in that nation.
(B) The level of human indicators in a nation is irrelevant to the welfare of the individuals in that nation.
(C) A high per capita GNP in a nation usually indicates that the wealth in the nation is not distributed across the society as a whole.
(D) The welfare of a nation’s residents is irrelevant to the economic health of the nation.
(E) The use of indicators other than material wealth to measure economic well-being would benefit a nation.

7 
 7. In the passage, the author’s primary concern is to

(A) delineate a new method of directing domestic economic efforts
(B) point out the weaknesses in one standard for measuring a nation’s welfare
(C) explain the fact that some nations have both a high per capita GNP and a low quality of life for its citizens
(D) demonstrate that unequal distribution of wealth is an inevitable result of a high per capita GNP
(E) argue that political economists alone should be responsible for economic policy decisions

Source:   LSAT Official PrepTest 33   
 Difficulty Level:   700

RC Butler 2021  -  Practice Two RC Questions Everyday.   
Passage # 201 Date: 21-May-2021
 This question is a part of RC Butler 2021 .  Click here for Details

LaveenaPanchal · Accepted Answer

1. Which one of the following titles most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

(A) “The Shifting Meaning of Per Capita GNP: A Historical Perspective”.  Incorrect. Meaning of Per Capita GNP is only explained. No Shifting in meaning considered.  
(B) “A Defense of Per Capita GNP: An Economist’s Rejoinder”.  Incorrect. Per Capita GNP is not defensed. In fact its weakness are provided in the passage. 
(C) “The Preferability of Human Indicators as Measures of National Economic Health”.  Correct. The human indicators are the preferred as measures of National Economic Health. 
(D) “Total Wealth vs. Distribution of Wealth as a Measure of Economic Health”.  Incorrect. Its only mentioned in the passage.
 Its not the main point. 
(E) “A New Method of Calculating Per Capita GNP to Measure National Economic Health”.  Incorrect. No new method described in the passage.

2. The term “welfare” is used in the first paragraph to refer most specifically to which one of the following?

(A) the overall quality of life for individuals in a nation.  Correct. Examples of human indicators suggest the quality of life for individuals in a nation. 
(B) the services provided to individuals by a government.  Incorrect. Partial scope. Only one of the human indicators. 
(C) the material wealth owned by individuals in a nation.  Incorrect. it is not discussed in the first paragraph. 
(D) the extent to which the distribution of wealth among individuals in a nation is balanced. Incorrect. it is not discussed in the first paragraph. 
(E) government efforts to redistribute wealth across society as a whole.  Incorrect not discusssed in the passage .

3. The passage provides specific information about each of the following EXCEPT:

(A) how per capita GNP is calculated.
(B) what many political economists believe to be an accurate measure of a nation’s economic health
(C) how nations with a relatively low per capita GNP can sometimes be economically healthier than nations whose per capita GNP is higher
(D) why human indicators may not provide the same picture of a nation’s economic health that per capita GNP does
(E) how nations can adjust their domestic economic efforts to bring about substantial improvements in per capita GNP.  Correct. No such idea discussed in the passage.

4. Which one of the following scenarios, if true, would most clearly be a counterexample to the views expressed in the last paragraph of the passage?

(A) The decision by a nation with a low level of economic health as measured by human indicators to focus on increasing the levels of human indicators results in slower growth in its per capita GNP.
(B) The decision by a nation with a low level of economic health as measured by human indicators to focus on increasing domestic production of goods results in significant improvements in the levels of human indicators.  Correct. In Paragraph 3, it is stated that a nation should divert its focus to increase the level of human indicators however as per this choice the shift towards increase in GNP increases the level of economic health. So this action is opposite to what is mentioned in third paragraph 
(C) The decision by a nation with a low level of economic health as measured by human indicators to focus on increasing the levels of human indicators results in increased growth in per capita GNP.
(D) The decision by a nation with a low per capita GNP to focus on improving its level of economic health as measured by human indicators fails to bring about an increase in per capita GNP.
(E) The decision by a nation with a low per capita GNP to focus on increasing domestic production of goods fails to improve its economic health as measured by human indicators.

5. The primary function of the last paragraph of the passage is to

(A) offer a synthesis of the opposing positions outlined in the first two paragraphs..  Incorrect. First two paragraph are not opposite but in same direction. 
(B) expose the inadequacies of both positions outlined in the first two paragraphs.  Incorrect. There is a single position in the first two paragraphs. 
(C) summarize the argument made in the first two paragraphs. Incorrect.  Third paragraph states the implications of adopting the policies as per two paragraphs.  
(D) correct a weakness in the political economists’ position as outlined in the second paragraph.  Incorrect.  
(E) suggest policy implications of the argument made in the first two paragraphs.  Correct.

6. Based on the passage, the political economists discussed in the passage would be most likely to agree with which one of the following statements?

(A) A change in a nation’s per capita GNP predicts a similar future change in the state of human indicators in that nation.  Correct. It is mentioned in the first sentence of second paragraph. 
(B) The level of human indicators in a nation is irrelevant to the welfare of the individuals in that nation.  Incorrect. Not mentioned in the passage. 
(C) A high per capita GNP in a nation usually indicates that the wealth in the nation is not distributed across the society as a whole.  Incorrect. This is not mentioned in the passage. 
(D) The welfare of a nation’s residents is irrelevant to the economic health of the nation.  Incorrect. This is not mentioned in the passage. 
(E) The use of indicators other than material wealth to measure economic well-being would benefit a nation.  Incorrect. This is author's viewpoint.

7. In the passage, the author’s primary concern is to

(A) delineate a new method of directing domestic economic efforts.  Incorrect. The author describes the better indicators of economic level of nation but not the method. 
(B) point out the weaknesses in one standard for measuring a nation’s welfare.  Correct. The weakness of Per Capita GNP as an economic welfare indicator is the purpose of passage. 
(C) explain the fact that some nations have both a high per capita GNP and a low quality of life for its citizens.  Incorrect. partial scope. 
(D) demonstrate that unequal distribution of wealth is an inevitable result of a high per capita GNP.  Incorrect Partial Scope. 
(E) argue that political economists alone should be responsible for economic policy decisions.  Incorrect. No such argument made.

mahakbansal8786 · Answer

Sajjad1994  
could you please explain why in question 2 ans is option 1
In para 1, welfare hasn't been defined but in "The welfare of a nation’s
(40) residents is a matter not merely of total economic
benefit, but also of the distribution of economic
benefits across the entire society." it is given what welfare entails. So according to that shouldn't the answer be option 2?

AnirudhaS · Answer

Line 40 is para 2. The question asks what the author meant by welfare in para 1.

Many political economists believe that the soundest
indicator of the economic health of a nation is the
nation’s gross national product (GNP) per capita—a
figure reached by dividing the total value of the goods
(5) produced yearly in a nation by its population and taken
to be a measure of the welfare of the nation’s residents.
 But there are many factors affecting residents’ welfare
that are not captured by per capita GNP ; human
indicators, while sometimes more difficult to calculate
(10) or document, provide sounder measures of a nation’s
progress than does the indicator championed by these
economists. These human indicators include nutrition
and life expectancy; birth weight and level of infant
mortality; ratio of population level to availability of
(15) resources; employment opportunities; and the ability of
governments to provide services such as education,
clean water, medicine, public transportation, and mass
communication for their residents.

the bold part is the answer. It says there are other factors -
-nutrition & life expectancy; 
-birth weight and level of infant mortality; 
-ratio of population level to availability of resources; 
-employment opportunities; 
-the ability of governments to provide services such as education, clean water, medicine, public transportation,
-mass communication for their residents.

Essentially all these factors can be grouped under "overall quality of life"

Hope this helps.

PJ226 · Answer

Sajjad1994  Could you please provide an explanation for question no. 3? I am unable to eliminate option D.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Official Explanation

3. The passage provides specific information about each of the following EXCEPT:

Difficulty Level:   700

Explanation

Pinpointing the information mentioned in the four wrong choices may be the fastest way to identify the choice that goes undescribed.  (A)  is clearly  lines 3-6 , and the full sentence in  lines 1-6 addresses (B). (C)  is explained in  lines 55-58 , while those same lines, not to mention  lines 28-39 , go into detail as to (D)’s issue (as well they might; (D)’s issue is at the heart of the entire argument). But  (E)  is never discussed, and no wonder: Why would the author include information as to how to improve the very measuring factor—per capita GNP—that he wants nations to eschew?

Answer: E

pintukr · Answer

1. Which one of the following titles most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

(A) “The Shifting Meaning of Per Capita GNP: A Historical Perspective”
 There is no mention of past v/s now in the passage

(B) “A Defense of Per Capita GNP: An Economist’s Rejoinder”
 Opposite to the stimulus will be true..Per Capita GNP has been proposed to be discarded in favor of Human Indicators to measure the Economic health

(C) “The Preferability of Human Indicators as Measures of National Economic Health”
 Clearly highlights the focus of the passage. The preference for Human Indicators to measure the Economic Health has been emphasized throughout the passage

(D) “Total Wealth vs. Distribution of Wealth as a Measure of Economic Health”
 Though mentioned in first paragraph, it's not the focus of the passage as a whole

(E) “A New Method of Calculating Per Capita GNP to Measure National Economic Health”
 New method/technique has not been emphasized; rather the preference for Human Indicators to measure the Economic Health has been emphasized

(C) is the CORRECT answer

pintukr · Answer

2. The term “welfare” is used in the first paragraph to refer most specifically to which one of the following?

(A) the overall quality of life for individuals in a nation
  Lines 12-18 of the 1st paragraph clearly summarize into 'the overall quality of life'

(B) the services provided to individuals by a government
 services is just a subset of the whole concept of welfare mentioned in the 1st paragraph

(C) the material wealth owned by individuals in a nation
 material wealth is not implied here

(D) the extent to which the distribution of wealth among individuals in a nation is balanced
 welfare , as mentioned in the 1st paragraph, doesn't highlight the distribution of health

(E) government efforts to redistribute wealth across society as a whole
 government efforts also just forms a subset of the whole concept of welfare mentioned in the 1st paragraph

(A) is the CORRECT answer

pintukr · Answer

3. The passage provides specific information about each of the following EXCEPT:

(A) how per capita GNP is calculated
 Paragraph 1 mentions this aspect

(B) what many political economists believe to be an accurate measure of a nation’s economic health
 The opening lines of the Paragraph 1 highlights the measure as per many political economists

(C) how nations with a relatively low per capita GNP can sometimes be economically healthier than nations whose per capita GNP is higher
 An implication after understanding lines 30-35 in the 2nd paragraph

(D) why human indicators may not provide the same picture of a nation’s economic health that per capita GNP does
 Mentioned in the lines 39-40 in the 2nd paragraph

(E) how nations can adjust their domestic economic efforts to bring about substantial improvements in per capita GNP
  No discussion in the passage regarding this aspect; CORRECT answer

(E) is the CORRECT answer

pintukr · Answer

4. Which one of the following scenarios, if true, would most clearly be a counterexample to the views expressed in the last paragraph of the passage?

Clearly, the passage highlights the human indicators driving the economic health; hence, a counterexample is likely to focus on measures/initiatives away from those that are directed towards increasing the levels of human indicators.

(A) The decision by a nation with a low level of economic health as measured by human indicators to focus on increasing the levels of human indicators results in slower growth in its per capita GNP.
 GNP growth is not the focus of the author's views as expressed in the last paragraph

(B) The decision by a nation with a low level of economic health as measured by human indicators to focus on increasing domestic production of goods results in significant improvements in the levels of human indicators.
  In line with our pre-thinking; highlights other measures , ie the measures/initiatives 'away' from those that are directed towards increasing the levels of human indicators

(C) The decision by a nation with a low level of economic health as measured by human indicators to focus on increasing the levels of human indicators results in increased growth in per capita GNP.
 per capita GNP growth is not the focus of the author's views as expressed in the last paragraph

(D) The decision by a nation with a low per capita GNP to focus on improving its level of economic health as measured by human indicators fails to bring about an increase in per capita GNP.
 here also, the per capita GNP growth is not the focus of the author's views as expressed in the last paragraph

(E) The decision by a nation with a low per capita GNP to focus on increasing domestic production of goods fails to improve its economic health as measured by human indicators.
 In line with the argument of the passage as a whole

(B) is the CORRECT answer

pintukr · Answer

5. The primary function of the last paragraph of the passage is to

The last paragraph focuses on the measures to be initiated by the nations in respect of their economic efforts. Such focus areas are the implications arising out of the understanding of the issues presented in the first two paragraphs.

(A) offer a synthesis of the opposing positions outlined in the first two paragraphs
 last paragraph draws implications on basis of arguments presented in the first two paragraphs

(B) expose the inadequacies of both positions outlined in the first two paragraphs
 implications are described, not inadequacies of positions outlined in the first two paragraphs

(C) summarize the argument made in the first two paragraphs
 No, it's not the summary; rather, the implications on method for directing the economic efforts

(D) correct a weakness in the political economists’ position as outlined in the second paragraph
 this aspect of correcting the weaknesses in the political economists’ position --- is a part of 1st and 2nd paragraph; the 3rd paragraph deals with consequent implications

(E) suggest policy implications of the argument made in the first two paragraphs
  In line with our pre-thinking ie, the last paragraph focuses on the measures to be initiated by the nations in respect of their economic efforts. Such focus areas are the implications arising out of the understanding of the issues presented in the first two paragraphs.  
 
 (E) is the CORRECT answer

pintukr · Answer

6. Based on the passage, the political economists discussed in the passage would be most likely to agree with which one of the following statements? 
 
It's a 'direct reference' question. 
  Reference from the Passage. (Lines 19-24 in 2nd paragraph)       The economists defend their use of per capita GNP as the sole measure of a nation’s economic health by claiming that improvements in per capita GNP eventually stimulate improvements in human indicators.

(A) A change in a nation’s per capita GNP predicts a similar future change in the state of human indicators in that nation.
  Reference from the passage (as presented above)

(B) The level of human indicators in a nation is irrelevant to the welfare of the individuals in that nation.
 No denial of such sort can be attributed to the political economists

(C) A high per capita GNP in a nation usually indicates that the wealth in the nation is not distributed across the society as a whole.
It's the author's implication, not the view of political economists

(D) The welfare of a nation’s residents is irrelevant to the economic health of the nation.
 Contrary to the views of the political economists

(E) The use of indicators other than material wealth to measure economic well-being would benefit a nation.
 material wealth can't be discounted, as the per capita GNP factors the calculations on the basis of material wealth 
 
 (A) is the CORRECT answer

pintukr · Answer

7. In the passage, the author’s primary concern is to

(A) delineate a new method of directing domestic economic efforts
 only the policy implications have been presented, ie, a focus away from per capita GNP

(B) point out the weaknesses in one standard for measuring a nation’s welfare
  The passage as a whole highlights the weaknesses in the per capita GNP approach, and consequent policy implications...CORRECT answer

(C) explain the fact that some nations have both a high per capita GNP and a low quality of life for its citizens
 may or may not be true..not the focus of the passage

(D) demonstrate that unequal distribution of wealth is an inevitable result of a high per capita GNP
 only an implication of the current method of 'per capita GNP' approach.

(E) argue that political economists alone should be responsible for economic policy decisions
 No such claims presented in the passage

(B) is the CORRECT answer

Nikhil_Rai · Answer

@GMATNinja/  Sajjad1994  Could you please explain how to eliminate Option A in Q5 here?

Carcass · Answer

They recognize  that unless a shift  in focus away from
using material wealth as the sole indicator of economic
success is effected, the well-being of the nation may be
(55) endangered,  and that nations that do well according
to human indicators may thrive even if their per capita
GNP remains stable or lags behind that of other
nations.

From the highlighted pèortion clearly, the last paragraph  is suggesting something  and not a  synthesis of the opposing positions

A is wrong for this reason.

I hope this helps

Many political economists believe that the soundest indicator of the

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

Many political economists believe that the soundest indicator of the

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards