Roadblocks on major holidays, even if they are set up only

Question

v05#2 
 Roadblocks on major holidays, even if they are set up only to check drivers’ licenses and seat belts, are spontaneous searches of every driver, even the ones who have committed no crime.  Without establishing probable cause, I believe such searches should be illegal.

A Without establishing probable cause, I believe such searches should be illegal
B Unless establishing probable cause, such searches, I believe, should be illegal
C I believe such searches should be illegal, without establishing probable cause
D I believe such searches should be illegal, unless officers have established probable cause
E I believe without establishing probable cause that such searches should be illegal

sondenso · Answer

Between C and D, I choose D even though C sounds good. :lol:

cumic · Answer

Another D.

One question though, Are A and C same in the meaning? I mean, does placing the dependent clause before and/or after the independent clause, changes the meaning?

lexis · Answer

B is my choice.

Who does establish probable cause? Searcher!

huntgmat · Answer

Roadblocks on major holidays, even if they are set up only to check drivers’ licenses and seat belts, are spontaneous searches of every driver, even the ones who have committed no crime. Without establishing probable cause, I believe such searches should be illegal.

A Without establishing probable cause, I believe such searches should be illegal
Incorrect: "Without ... cause" in above is like a modifier. It modifies "I" , which
actually makes no sense. As "I" is not establishing the cause. 
B Unless establishing probable cause, such searches, I believe, should be illegal
Incorrect:  Same as A. But even more serious with non-restrictive "such searches"  
C I believe such searches should be illegal, without establishing probable cause
Incorrect: The modifier is shifted to end of the statement, modifying "illegal"  
D I believe such searches should be illegal, unless officers have established probable cause
Correct: This really makes sense. The format now is IC,DC=> IC,unless IC
And it is clear that "officiers" established a cause. 
E I believe without establishing probable cause that such searches should be illegal
Incorrect: Odd. I believe without establishing .... I don't establish

mohit879 · Answer

I got the answer as D. Let me explain:

This is one of those in which we need to reduce ambiguity. First off, we should be able to establish that the author of the argument thinks that random searches without probable cause are illegal.

Without establishing probable cause, I believe such searches should be illegal 
Without establishing probable cause, I believe 
This tells us that author does not have a probable cause for his belief. Wrong meaning. NO.

Unless establishing probable cause, such searches, I believe, should be illegal 
Unless establishing probable cause 
This is a sentence fragment. For this sentence to be correct, the bold should have been "Unless probable cause is established, ....NO.

I believe such searches should be illegal, without establishing probable cause 
Again, the meaning here is ambiguous, this sentence reads as if the author has not established probable cause. NO.

I believe such searches should be illegal, unless officers have established probable cause 
This is the correct answer. It correctly addresses the authors concern, and we can clearly see who needs to establish the probable cause. YES.

I believe without establishing probable cause that such searches should be illegal 
Again, it means the same wrong meaning as A and C, therefore not correct. NO.

Let me know if this helps

Avinashs87 · Answer

/

'Without' something happening...." " should be illegal does not sound right. 'Unless' fits in better!

There fore option A,C,E are out. Option B sounds awkward....Hence option E is the correct choice.

agar123 · Answer

Hi,
can someone explain the meaning and the answer choice explanation in detail?

Regards,

jaisonsunny77 · Answer

Roadblocks on major holidays, even if they are set up only to check drivers’ licenses and seat belts, are spontaneous searches of every driver, even the ones who have committed no crime.   Without establishing probable cause, I believe such searches should be illegal.

A  Without establishing probable cause, I believe such searches should be illegal
  - Who is performing the action of 'establishing' ? (A) does not mention the subject who commands the action of 'establishing'. Hence,  eliminate (A)

B  Unless establishing probable cause, such searches, I believe, should be illegal  - The same error in (A): 
Who is performing the action of 'establishing' ? (A) does not mention the subject who commands the action of 'establishing'. Hence,  eliminate (B)

C  I believe such searches should be illegal, without establishing probable cause  - Same error as in (A): (C) has no clear subject that commands the action of 'establishing'. Hence,  eliminate (C). 
 
D  I believe such searches should be illegal, unless officers have established probable cause  - Here, we know exactly 'who' is commanding the action of 'establishing'. Additionally, the usage of 'unless' clearly indicates an exception to the general statement made by the author of the passage. (D) has no logical error or grammatical error. Hence,   (D) is the right answer.  
 
E  I believe without establishing probable cause that such searches should be illegal  - the pronoun 'that' is misplaced here. In (E), 'that' now modifies 'cause', a modifier action that does not make sense. Hence,  eliminate (E).

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

Roadblocks on major holidays, even if they are set up only

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

Roadblocks on major holidays, even if they are set up only

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards