Official Solution:
Company policy: An employee of our company must be impartial, particularly when dealing with family matters. This obligation extends to all aspects of the job, including hiring and firing practices and the quality of service the employee provides customers.
Which one of the following employee behaviors most clearly violates the company policy cited above?
A. Refusing to hire any of one’s five siblings, even though they are each more qualified than any other applicant
B. Receiving over 100 complaints about the service one’s office provides and sending a complimentary product to all those who complain, including one’s mother
C. Never firing a family member, even though three of one’s siblings work under one’s supervision and authority
D. Repeatedly refusing to advance an employee, claiming that he has sometimes skipped work and that his work has been sloppy, even though no such instances have occurred for over two years
E. Promoting a family member over another employee in the company
When you read about impartiality in the workplace and family members, you automatically think about nepotism. You think that the correct answer must be something that relates to unfair bias toward a family member, because that is what your mind expects. But when you read through the answer choices, the only one that must violate the policy is the opposite of what you expect: Given the defined policy in the stimulus, if you do not hire one of your siblings and they are each more qualified than ANY OTHER APPLICANT, then that is necessarily unfair. While you might first be drawn to answer choice C or E, you do not know if those actions are unfair.
In answer choice C, for example, the family members may never have done anything that would prompt a firing.
And the family member in choice E might have fully deserved a promotion.
Only choice A, the correct answer, supplies a case that violates the rule. It just so happens, however, that that case is the one you wouldn’t expect to be a problem. You expect for the rule to champion anti-nepotism, and the author of this question uses that tendency against you.
Answer: A