I'm inclined not to include it. Please assess the validity of my rationale. Why Not?
(1) It's relatively easy for AdComs to spot other schools' essay topics addressed in their optional (assuming, of course, you use another schools' essay as your optional)
(2) I lack major "gliches" in my application that must be explained away (i.e. low GPA, odd choice of recommenders, etc)
(3) Too much information: this will only annoy application readers already boged down and behind schedule.
On the other hand, methinks it might be a good idea for Yale b/c they only have two required essays.
Thoughts?
Rhyme---
Feel free to write another short story on this one. I had to forward your last gem to all of my buddies around the office.