Hey HoyaSaxa,
I'm in a similar boat.
If I'm not mistaken, Stern has a Luxury Goods/Retail concentration, so obviously that would be ideal if you want to end up in NYC.
Johnson also has a great brand management program, and they have heavy alumni and recruiting connections to NYC.
Also, Kelley has one of the best consumer marketing programs in the country, and focus heavily on the quant/analytical aspects of marketing. The only caveat is that most of their recruiting companies and alumni are based in the Midwest.
Also, if you're serious about really focusing on refining your hard, numbers skills, you should look into Tepper, Simon, and Sloan.
And finally, there's always Kellogg, Wharton, and Fuqua- the big 3 for marketing.