Was Felix Mendelssohn (1809—1847) a great composer? On its face, the q

Question

New Project RC Butler 2019  -  Practice 2 RC Passages Everyday   
Passage # 426, Date: 01-Nov-2019
 This post is a part of New Project RC Butler 2019 .  Click here for Details

Was Felix Mendelssohn (1809—1847) a great composer? On its face, the question seems absurd. One of the most gifted prodigies in the history of music, he produced his first masterpiece at sixteen. From then on, he was recognized as an artist of preternatural abilities, not only as a composer but also as a pianist and conductor. But Mendelssohn’s enduring popularity has often been at odds — sometimes quite sharply — with his critical standing. Despite general acknowledgment of his genius, there has been a noticeable reluctance to rank him with, say, Schumann or Brahms. As Haggin put it, Mendelssohn, as a composer, was a “minor master … working on a small scale of emotion and texture.”   1 
 C 
 1. The passage suggests that anyone attempting to evaluate Mendelssohn’s career must confront which of the following dichotomies?

A. The tension between Mendelssohn’s career as a composer and his career as a pianist and conductor
B. The contrast between Mendelssohn’s popularity and that of Schumann and Brahms
C. The discrepancy between Mendelssohn’s popularity and his standing among critics
D. The inconsistency between Mendelssohn’s reputation during his lifetime and his reputation since his death
E. The gap between Mendelssohn’s prodigious musical beginnings and his decline in later years

2 
 D 
 2. It can be inferred that the “reluctance” mentioned in the passage is being ascribed to

A. most composers since Mendelssohn
B. Schumann and Brahms
C. the music-listening public
D. music critics generally
E. Haggin exclusively

3 
 E 
 3. The author mentions Schumann and Brahms primarily in order to

A. provide examples of composers who are often compared with Mendelssohn
B. identify certain composers who are more popular than Mendelssohn
C. identify composers whom Mendelssohn influenced
D. establish the milieu in which Mendelssohn worked
E. establish a standard of comparison for Mendelssohn as a composer

120/826

Tracy95 · Answer

The questions seem to be easy and answers are explicitly stated in the passage. 
 1. The passage suggests that anyone attempting to evaluate Mendelssohn’s career must confront which of the following dichotomies? 
=> "But Mendelssohn’s enduring popularity has often been at odds — sometimes quite sharply — with his critical standing."
=> So choice (C): The discrepancy between Mendelssohn’s popularity and his standing among critics

2. It can be inferred that the “reluctance” mentioned in the passage is being ascribed to 
=> "Despite general acknowledgment of his genius, there has been a noticeable reluctance to rank him with, say, Schumann or Brahms."
=> "reluctance" is ascribed to music critics. Though Mendelssohn was popular, he didn't earn a good stand among music critics. We can see one cited comment by Haggin, who might be a music critic, that clearly doesn't favor Mendelssohn, saying “minor master … working on a small scale of emotion and texture." 
=> So choice (D): music critics generally

3. The author mentions Schumann and Brahms primarily in order to 
=> The author is trying to compare Mendelssohn with other music talents whom the author regards as standard.
=> So choice (E): establish a standard of comparison for Mendelssohn as a composer

himanshu119 · Answer

please provide official solutions for all the questions

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Official Explanation

1. The passage suggests that anyone attempting to evaluate Mendelssohn’s career must confront which of the following dichotomies?

Difficulty Level:   600

Explanation

The passage clearly presents the discrepancy between Mendelssohn’s popularity and his critical standing as an interpretive problem. Therefore,  Choice C  is correct. The other answer choices are incorrect because the passage never indicates that there was any conﬂict among the different aspects of Mendelssohn’s professional life; never discusses Schumann’s and Brahms’s popularity; does not discuss any differences between Mendelssohn’s reputation during his lifetime and after his death; and makes no mention of a decline in Mendelssohn’s later life.

Answer: C

2. It can be inferred that the “reluctance” mentioned in the passage is being ascribed to

Difficulty Level:   550

Explanation

Choice D  is correct. The  “reluctance”  is mentioned in the context of a discussion about Mendelssohn’s critical standing and thus is being ascribed to music critics generally.

Choices A and B  can be eliminated because the passage does not discuss any composers’ views of Mendelssohn.

Choice C  is incorrect because the word  “reluctance”  is mentioned only after the passage turns from discussing the popular view of Mendelssohn to the critical view.

Choice E  is incorrect because the words  “As Haggin put it”  indicate that Haggin is only one example of critics who have this reluctance.

Answer: D

3. The author mentions Schumann and Brahms primarily in order to

Difficulty Level:   600

Explanation

Schumann and Brahms are mentioned as a way of explaining how critics rank Mendelssohn — that is, as less accomplished than some other composers who are widely acknowledged as major. Therefore,  Choice E  is correct.

Choice A  might look like a correct answer at first glance. However, careful consideration reveals that the point the author is making when Schumann and Brahms are mentioned is not the frequency of that comparison but the results of it. Therefore,  Choice A  can be eliminated.

Choices B, C, and D  are incorrect because the passage does not discuss Schumann’s and Brahms’s popularity, Mendelssohn’s inﬂuence on other composers, or the milieu in which Mendelssohn worked.

Answer: E

Hope it helps

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

Was Felix Mendelssohn (1809—1847) a great composer? On its face, the q

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

Was Felix Mendelssohn (1809—1847) a great composer? On its face, the q

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards