The genius of American democracy comes not from any special virtue of the American people but from the unprecedented opportunities of this continent and from a peculiar and unrepeatable combination of historical circumstances. These circumstances have given our institutions their character and their virtues. The very same facts which explain these virtues, explain also our inability to make a “philosophy” of them.
They explain, therefore, why we have nothing in the line of a theory that can be exported to other peoples of the world. We should not ask others to adopt our “philosophy” because we have no philosophy which can be exported. My argument is simple. It is based on forgotten commonplaces of American history– facts so obvious that we no longer see them. I argue, in a word, that American democracy is unique. It possesses a “genius” all its own. By this I mean what the Romans might have described as the tutelary spirit assigned to our nation at its birth and presiding over its destiny. Or what we more prosaically might call a characteristic disposition of our culture.From the lines above clearly is E
A. we have a critic whatsoever in the passage
B, C are not stated. In particular, C is really off the ranch. We do not have an alternative way to explain American Democracy. Rather, we do have a neutral tone that explains WHY it has a peculiar characteristic and why this cannot be applied anywhere else
D we do not have the complexities faced we do have rather why the US democracy is "genius"
E is the answer
The source is from my archive