In music, a certain complexity of sounds can be expected to have a pos

Question

Passage A

In music, a certain complexity of sounds can be
expected to have a positive effect on the listener. A
single, pure tone is not that interesting to explore; a
measure of intricacy is required to excite human
  (5)   curiosity. Sounds that are too complex or disorganized,
however, tend to be overwhelming. We prefer some
sort of coherence, a principle that connects the various
sounds and makes them comprehensible.

In this respect, music is like human language.
  (10)   Single sounds are in most cases not sufficient to
convey meaning in speech, whereas when put together
in a sequence they form words and sentences.
Likewise, if the tones in music are not perceived to be
tied together sequentially or rhythmically—for
  (15)   example, in what is commonly called melody—
listeners are less likely to feel any emotional
connection or to show appreciation.

Certain music can also have a relaxing effect. The
fact that such music tends to be continuous and
  (20)   rhythmical suggests a possible explanation for this
effect. In a natural environment, danger tends to be
accompanied by sudden, unexpected sounds. Thus, a
background of constant noise suggests peaceful
conditions; discontinuous sounds demand more
  (25)   attention. Even soft discontinuous sounds that we
consciously realize do not signal danger can be
disturbing—for example, the erratic dripping of a
leaky tap. A continuous sound, particularly one that is
judged to be safe, relaxes the brain.

Passage B

(30)   There are certain elements within music, such
as a change of melodic line or rhythm, that create
expectations about the future development of the
music. The expectation the listener has about the
further course of musical events is a key determinant
  (35)   for the experience of “musical emotions.” Music
creates expectations that, if not immediately satisfied,
create tension. Emotion is experienced in relation to
the buildup and release of tension. The more elaborate
the buildup of tension, the more intense the emotions
  (40)   that will be experienced. When resolution occurs,
relaxation follows.

The interruption of the expected musical course,
depending on one’s personal involvement, causes the
search for an explanation. This results from a
  (45)   “mismatch” between one’s musical expectation and
the actual course of the music. Negative emotions will be
the result of an extreme mismatch between
expectations and experience. Positive emotions result
if the converse happens.

(50)   When we listen to music, we take into account
factors such as the complexity and novelty of the
music. The degree to which the music sounds familiar
determines whether the music is experienced as
pleasurable or uncomfortable. The pleasure
  (55)   experienced is minimal when the music is entirely new
to the listener, increases with increasing familiarity,
and decreases again when the music is totally known.
Musical preference is based on one’s desire to
maintain a constant level of certain preferable
  (60)   emotions. As such, a trained listener will have a
greater preference for complex melodies than will a
naive listener, as the threshold for experiencing
emotion is higher.    1 
 1. Which one of the following concepts is linked to positive musical experiences in both passages?

(A) continuous sound
(B) tension
(C) language
(D) improvisation
(E) complexity

2 
 2. The passages most strongly suggest that both are targeting an audience that is interested in which one of the following?

(A) the theoretical underpinnings of how music is composed
(B) the nature of the conceptual difference between music and discontinuous sound
(C) the impact music can have on human emotional states
(D) the most effective techniques for teaching novices to appreciate complex music
(E) the influence music has had on the development of spoken language

3 
 3. Which one of the following describes a preference that is most analogous to the preference mentioned in the first paragraph of passage A?

(A) the preference of some people for falling asleep to white noise, such as the sound of an electric fan
(B) the preference of many moviegoers for movies with plots that are clear and easy to follow
(C) the preference of many diners for restaurants that serve large portions
(D) the preference of many young listeners for fast music over slower music
(E) the preference of most children for sweet foods over bitter foods

4 
 4. Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of passa ge B?

(A) The type of musical emotion experienced by a listener is determined by the level to which the listener’s expectations are satisfied.
(B) Trained listeners are more able to consciously manipulate their own emotional experiences of complex music than are naive listeners.
(C) If the development of a piece of music is greatly at odds with the listener’s musical expectations, then the listener will experience negative emotions.
(D) Listeners can learn to appreciate changes in melodic line and other musical complexities.
(E) Music that is experienced by listeners as relaxing usually produces a buildup and release of tension in those listeners.

5 
 5. Which one of the following most undermines the explanation provided in passage A for the relaxing effect that some music has on listeners?

(A) The musical traditions of different cultures vary greatly in terms of the complexity of the rhythms they employ.
(B) The rhythmic structure of a language is determined in part by the pattern of stressed syllables in the words and sentences of the language.
(C) Many people find the steady and rhythmic sound of a rocking chair to be very unnerving.
(D) The sudden interruption of the expected development of a melody tends to interfere with listeners’ perception of the melody as coherent.
(E) Some of the most admired contemporary composers write music that is notably simpler than is most of the music written in previous centuries.

6 
 6. Which one of the following would be most appropriate as a title for each of the passages?

(A) “The Biological Underpinnings of Musical Emotions”
(B) “The Psychology of Listener Response to Music”
(C) “How Music Differs from Other Art Forms”
(D) “Cultural Patterns in Listeners’ Responses to Music”
(E) “How Composers Convey Meaning Through Music”

7 
 7. It can be inferred that both authors would be likely to agree with which one of the following statements?

(A) The more complex a piece of music, the more it is likely to be enjoyed by most listeners.
(B) More knowledgeable listeners tend to prefer music that is discontinuous and unpredictable.
(C) The capacity of music to elicit strong emotional responses from listeners is the central determinant of its artistic value.
(D) Music that lacks a predictable course is unlikely to cause a listener to feel relaxed.
(E) Music that changes from soft to loud is perceived as disturbing and unpleasant by most listeners.

RC Butler 2022  -  Practice Two RC Passages Everyday.   
Passage # 318 Date: 09-Aug-2022
 This question is a part of RC Butler 2022 .  Click here for Details

Source:   LSAT Official PrepTest 58   
 Difficulty Level:   700

Prathana · Answer

Please explain the reasoning used in Q3 and Q7.

Posted from my mobile device

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Question #3:

For the gist of passage A's discussion, look at this sentence:  "We prefer some sort of coherence, a principle that connects the various sounds and makes them comprehensible."

According to passage A, we need to be able to make sense of music. The patterns into which it is organized need to be just complex enough to arouse our interest, but not so complicated that we cannot comprehend the pattern, and certainly not chaotic or disorganized.

In answer  choice (B) , there is a preference for movies that are clear and easy to follow. In other words, there are easy to comprehend and to keep up with, being organized (so there is not total chaos) but not so overly complicated that they overwhelm us. There is enough substance to keep us interested, but not so much that we get overwhelmed, and certainly nothing chaotic and confusing. This is the proper analogy with the first paragraph of passage A.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Question #7

Read the following lines from Passage A

In a natural environment, danger tends to be
accompanied by sudden, unexpected sounds. Thus, a
background of constant noise suggests peaceful
conditions; discontinuous sounds demand more
(25) attention. Even soft discontinuous sounds that we
consciously realize do not signal danger can be
disturbing—for example, the erratic dripping of a
leaky tap.

and the following lines from Passage B

The interruption of the expected musical course,
depending on one’s personal involvement, causes the
search for an explanation. This results from a
(45) “mismatch” between one’s musical expectation and
the actual course of the music.

D is supported.

Solenja · Answer

Hey Sajjad!

I'm just asking out of curiosity but can we expect such a long passages from gmat and if it does could you please suggest any tips ?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Hello Solenja

This passage originates from the Official LSAT Prep Test, the primary purpose to posts such long passages from LSAT is to provide quality practice material to our members, and there is no harm in practicing such passages. This passage is approx 480 words long and chances are very rare someone will come across such a long passage in the real GMAT test. The latest patterns of the real GMAT test suggest that a long passage might go up to 350-370 words accompanying 4 questions.

desertEagle · Answer

A
1) certain degree of Complexity of music -> +ve emotions
2) Analogy to human language 
3) Music -> Relaxing effect = continuity + rhythm

Summary - Characteristics of music which causes +ve effect(including relaxation)

B
1) expectation determines experience - 
2) Musical expectation vs experience - mismatch causes tension, match causes relaxation
3) Complexity and novelty/Familiarity 
Summary - Pleasure depends on complexity and familiarity

desertEagle · Answer

1. Which one of the following concepts is linked to positive musical experiences in both passages?

(A) continuous sound - only in passage A
(B) tension - not tension per se but resolution of tension provides +ve experience
(C) language - is used as an anlogy and does not have any bearing on experience
(D) improvisation - out of scope
(E) complexity - 
First line of passage A - In music, a certain complexity of sounds can be expected to have a positive effect on the listener. 
First line of 3rd paragraph of Passage B - When we listen to music, we take into account
factors such as the complexity and novelty of the
music.

Ans E

juri01m · Answer

Merry Christmas, could you please post the OE for Q1 and Q4? 
Thank you very much!

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

1. Which one of the following concepts is linked to positive musical experiences in both passages?

Difficulty Level:   700

Explanation

Both passages talk about positive musical experiences. Use the answers as your lead words and see what each passage says on the topic. You want an answer choice that both passages discuss.

A.  No. Passage B does not discuss continuous sound.

B.  No. Passage A does not discuss tension.

C.  No. Language is discussed only in the first paragraph and only as an analogy to music.

D.  No. Improvisation is not mentioned in either passage.

E.  Yes.   The second sentence of passage A and the entire last paragraph of passage B discuss how complexity is linked to a positive musical experience.

Answer: E

ChandlerBong · Answer

Hi Sajjad1994 , How can we eliminate (C) in Q7? Thanks in advance

Sajjad1994 · Answer

The author of passage A indicates that having a continuous sound makes music enjoyable to the listener. It makes the music safer and more predictable. Likewise, the author of passage B indicates that having the music match the listener's expectations, along with the buildup and release of tension, causes music to have a relaxing effect.

(C)  is Out of Scope. The artistic value of music is never discussed by either author. Rather, the passages focus on how and why those strongemotional responses from listeners are elicited.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Here it is  lewdtoucan

Explanation

5. Which one of the following most undermines the explanation provided in passage A for the relaxing effect that some music has on listeners?

Difficulty Level:   555-605

Step 1: Identify the Question Type

The correct answer choice will weaken the explanation provided in passage A for why some music has a relaxing effect on listeners.
 
  Step 2: Research the Relevant Text

The first two sentences in the third paragraph of passage A warrant attention. The author of passage A explains that the continuous and rhythmic nature of music produces a relaxing effect.
 
  Step 3: Make a Prediction

The correct answer choice will present a fact that makes it less likely or believable that the continuous and rhythmic nature of music produces a relaxing effect.
 
  Step 4: Evaluate the Answer Choices

(C)  is the correct answer. If people find the steady and rhythmic nature of a rocking chair to be stressful, then surely we could question whether the continuous sounds of music have a relaxing effect.
 
  (A)  is   Out of Scope  . The complexity of music is not offered in passage A as an explanation for why music has a relaxing effect.

(B)  is irrelevant. How the rhythmic sound is produced has no effect on whether the rhythm itself is still a valid reason for why the listener finds the music relaxing.
 
  (D)  is Out of Scope. The effect of expectations on the listenerʼs satisfaction and relaxation is a concept discussed in passage B.
 
  (E)  is irrelevant. Although passage A discusses the effect of simplicity on the listener, the amount of music that is written to be simpler now versus in the past is irrelevant to whether the listener experiences relaxation.

Answer: C

Agarwal2003 · Answer

Why can't A be the right answer? Both passages talk about that listeners like complexity

samarpan.g28 · Answer

Hi Agarwal2003 . You are correct that there are mentions of complexity in both passages. But let's check whether they relate to what option A suggests. Option A says, " The more complex a piece of music, the more it is likely to be enjoyed by most listeners. " In passage A, it is mentioned, " In music, a certain complexity of sounds can be expected to have a positive effect on the listener " and again, " Sounds that are too complex or disorganized, however, tend to be overwhelming. " Does it match with option A? No. Let's now focus on passage B. It mentions that " When we listen to music, we take into account factors such as the complexity and novelty of the music. The degree to which the music sounds familiar determines whether the music is experienced as pleasurable or uncomfortable. " and " As such, a trained listener will have a greater preference for complex melodies than will a naive listener, as the threshold for experiencing emotion is higher. " It is nowhere mentioned whether more complex music is liked by ' most listeners.' Option D, on the other hand, says that unpredictable music = discomfort . Passage A mentions, " Even soft discontinuous sounds that we consciously realize do not signal danger can be disturbing—for example, the erratic dripping of a leaky tap. A continuous sound, particularly one that is judged to be safe, relaxes the brain . " Okay, a good match. Passage B also mentions, " The pleasure experienced is minimal when the music is entirely new to the listener, increases with increasing familiarity, and decreases again when the music is totally known. Musical preference is based on one’s desire to maintain a constant level of certain preferable emotions. " A match! Makes sense? Let me know

In music, a certain complexity of sounds can be expected to have a pos

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

In music, a certain complexity of sounds can be expected to have a pos

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards