To some scholars, the European baroque is not merely an aesthetic styl

Question

To some scholars, the European baroque is not merely an aesthetic style characterized by extravagant forms and elaborate ornamentation, but also a political, social, and cultural mentality prevalent in Europe from approximately 1600 to 1680.  This larger view  was held by the late Spanish historian Jose Antonio Maravall, whose writings trace aspects of the modern world—especially the principle of individual liberty in opposition to the state's power—back to the baroque era as it unfolded in Spain.

Maravall argues that the baroque period was characterized by "monarchical absolutism": monarchs, having suppressed the worst excesses of aristocratic disorder, could now ally themselves with their nobilities to defend traditional order and values in societies unsettled by the Renaissance's liberating forces of criticism and opposition. These forces appeared especially threatening because deteriorating economic conditions heightened conflict among different elements of society. For Maravall, baroque culture was the response of the ruling class (including crown, Church, and nobility) to the European social and economic crisis, although that crisis was more acute, and the social structure more frozen, in imperial Spain than elsewhere. Maravall regards the baroque as a culture of control and containment, or, more dynamically, as a  directive  culture, designed to reintegrate and unite a society living under the shadow of social and intellectual disruption.

Maravall suggests that even though all the political controls were centralized in the monarchical system, this system of authority was not simply repressive. It was also enticing, promoting a public delight in  grandiose artifice  by means of devices that ranged from fireworks displays to theater to religious festivals. Operating upon an urban culture that already possessed characteristics of modern mass culture, these enticements deflected the desire for novelty into areas of life where it represented no challenge to the political order. Maravall concludes that every aspect of the baroque emerged from the necessity, as public opinion grew increasingly important, of manipulating opinions and feelings on a broad public scale.

Perhaps, however, Maravall's interpretation is overly influenced by his quest for baroque foreshadowings of "modernity" and by his experience of living under the Spanish dictator Franco. He  tends to exaggerate  the capacity of those in authority to manipulate a society for their  own ideological ends . A look at the seventeenth-century courts of Charles I in England or Philip IV in Spain suggests that efforts at manipulation were at times  wholly counterproductive . In England and Spain during the 1630s, the rulers themselves, not the subjects, succumbed to the illusions carefully sustained by ceremony, theater, and symbol. The result was that members of the ruling class became dangerously isolated from the outside world, and as the gulf between illusion and reality widened, the monarchy and aristocracy fell headlong into a credibility gap of their own creation.    1 
 1. Which one of the following best expresses the main idea of the passage?

(A) Until recently, the baroque has been regarded simply as an aesthetic style; however, Maravall has shown that it was a cultural mentality serving to reinforce monarchical absolutism.
(B) Maravall views baroque culture as a strategy for dissipating opposition and managing public opinion; however, he overestimates the strategy's success.
(C) Maravall interprets European baroque culture as an expansion of the social and intellectual developments of the Renaissance; however, his view of the seventeenth century is colored by his focus on Spain.
(D) MaravaU's theory about the intent of the ruling class to control society via baroque culture is refuted by the examples of specific baroque-era monarchies.
(E) According to the historian Maravall, baroque culture was a political construct designed essentially to control society and repress dissent.

2 
 2. Which one of the following phrases, in the context in which it occurs, most accurately indicates the author's attitude toward MaravaU's concept of baroque culture?

(A) "This larger view" (line 5)
(B) "grandiose artifice" (line 34)
(C) "tends to exaggerate" (lines 47-48)
(D) "own ideological ends" (line 49)
(E) "wholly counterproductive" (line 52)

3 
 3. Which one of the following words best expresses the meaning of "directive" as that word is used in line 27 of the passage?

(A) straightforward
(B) evolving
(C) codified
(D) guiding
(E) compelling

4 
 4. It can be inferred from the passage that Maravall regarded monarchs of the baroque era as

(A) increasingly indifferent to unfavorable public opinion
(B) concerned with the political threat posed by the aristocracy
(C) captivated by the cultural devices designed to control their subjects
(D) somewhat successful in countering the disruptive legacy of the Renaissance
(E) preoccupied with the goal of attaining cultural preeminence for their respective countries

5 
 5. In Maravall's view, baroque theater was intended to

(A) spur economic growth
(B) echo the consensus of public opinion
(C) entertain and divert the urban population
(D) express the emerging principle of individual liberty
(E) terrify the citizenry with the threat of monarchical repression

6 
 6. The main purpose of the passage is to

(A) contrast two competing theories and offer an evaluation
(B) challenge a widely accepted viewpoint by means of a counterexample
(C) explicate an interpretation and introduce a qualification
(D) articulate opposing arguments and propose a reconciliation
(E) explain the unprecedented consequences of a political construct

7 
 7. Which one of the following pieces of evidence if it existed. would most weaken Maravall's interpretation of baroque culture?

(A) confirmation that Maravall himself participated in opposing Franco's authoritarian regime
(B) the discovery that baroque-era nobility commissioned far more works of art than did the monarchs
(C) an analysis of baroque art that emphasizes its idealized depiction of the monarchy and aristocracy
(D) documents indicating that many baroque-era works of art expressed opposition to the monarchy
(E) documents indicating a conscious attempt on the part of Franco to control Spanish society by cultural means

DLCB8A533 · Answer

Could you please explain the answer to question number 5? I am not getting anything to relate to the divergence and entertainment of the urban population in the passage.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

5. In Maravall's view, baroque theater was intended to

Explanation

In Jose Antonio Maravall's view, the European Baroque is not just an aesthetic style but also a political, social, and cultural mentality that prevailed in Europe from approximately 1600 to 1680. This larger perspective sees the Baroque era as a response to the social and economic crisis in Europe and as a culture of control and containment. Maravall argues that it was a directive culture designed to reintegrate and unite societies facing disruption. Let's break down Maravall's interpretation and address the specific question about Baroque theater:

Characteristics of the Baroque Era:  Maravall believes that the Baroque period was characterized by  "monarchical absolutism."  Monarchs formed alliances with the nobility to defend traditional order and values in societies that were unsettled by the liberating forces of the Renaissance. This was a time when economic conditions deteriorated, leading to conflicts among different segments of society.

Baroque Culture as a Response:  According to Maravall, Baroque culture emerged as a response to this crisis. It was the creation of the ruling class, including the crown, Church, and nobility. Their goal was to maintain control and contain social and intellectual disruption.

Baroque Culture as Directive:  Maravall sees Baroque culture as a directive culture, designed to manipulate opinions and feelings on a broad public scale, especially as public opinion became increasingly important.

Enticements and Manipulation:  Maravall notes that while political controls were centralized in the monarchical system, it was not purely repressive. Instead, it was enticing. It promoted public delight in grandiose artifice through various means like fireworks displays, theater, and religious festivals. These enticements deflected the desire for novelty away from challenging the political order.

Public Opinion and Manipulation:  Maravall's perspective emphasizes the manipulation of opinions and feelings on a broad public scale as a key aspect of Baroque culture.

Now, let's address the specific question about Baroque theater:

Maravall's View on Baroque Theater: Maravall does not see Baroque theater as intended to  "spur economic growth" (Option A)  or  "express the emerging principle of individual liberty" (Option D) . Instead, he views Baroque theater as a means to  "entertain and divert the urban population" (Option C).  According to Maravall, theater, along with other forms of entertainment, was used as an enticing and diverting tool to maintain control and contain social disruption.

So, the correct answer to the question about Maravall's view on Baroque theater is:

Answer: C

AkankshaUniyal · Answer

Please explain question 4

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

4. It can be inferred from the passage that Maravall regarded monarchs of the baroque era as

Difficulty Level:   Hard

Explanation

(A) Incorrect:  The passage doesn't suggest that Maravall regarded monarchs as increasingly indifferent to unfavorable public opinion. In fact, Maravall discusses the manipulation of public opinion by the ruling class.

(B) Incorrect:  Maravall does mention that monarchs could ally themselves with the nobility to defend traditional order and values, but the passage doesn't specifically highlight concerns about a political threat posed by the aristocracy.

(C) Incorrect:  While Maravall does discuss the use of cultural devices by the ruling class, including monarchs, to control society, the term "captivated" implies a positive engagement, and the passage doesn't convey that the monarchs were captivated by these devices.

(D) Correct:   Maravall argues that the baroque period, characterized by monarchical absolutism, was a response to the social and economic crisis. He suggests that the political controls were centralized, and although enticing, they were designed to counter the disruptive forces of the Renaissance.

(E) Incorrect:  The passage doesn't provide evidence that Maravall believed monarchs were preoccupied with the goal of attaining cultural preeminence for their respective countries. The focus is more on using cultural elements for control in response to a crisis.

In summary,  (D)  is the correct answer because Maravall is portrayed as seeing the monarchs of the baroque era as somewhat successful in countering the disruptive legacy of the Renaissance through the implementation of political controls and cultural devices.

Answer: D

AkankshaUniyal · Answer

Maravall argues that the baroque period was characterized by "monarchical absolutism"; monarchs, having suppressed the worst excesses of aristocratic disorder, could now ally themselves with their nobilities  to defend traditional order and values in societies  unsettled by the Renaissance's liberating
forces of criticism and opposition

The line "to defend their traditional order and value in societies" seems to correspond with option E. (preoccupied with the goal of attaining cultural preeminence for their respective countries)
Please explain what I am missing.

Akarshkhan86 · Answer

Hello  sajjad1995 
Can you pl share the OE of Question 3 & 7. TIA

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

3. Which one of the following words best expresses the meaning of "directive" as that word is used in line 27 of the passage?

Difficulty Level:   650-700

Explanation

(A)  This term means clear, simple, or direct. In the context of the passage, the term "directive" is used to describe the nature of the culture, suggesting a form of guidance or control, not necessarily something clear or simple.

(B)  This term means developing or changing over time. In the passage, "directive culture" implies a form of control rather than something that is evolving. The baroque culture, as described by Maravall, is more about maintaining order and stability in response to social and economic crises.

(C)  This term refers to something that is organized and systematized into a code or set of laws. While the baroque culture described by Maravall involves control, it is not explicitly about having a rigid set of codified rules. It's more about responding dynamically to societal disruptions.

(D)  This term means directing, leading, or influencing. In the context of the passage, "directive culture" implies a form of guidance or control exercised by the ruling class to reintegrate and unite society under the shadow of disruption.

(E)  This term means forceful, persuasive, or having a powerful impact. In the passage, the "directive culture" is compelling in the sense that it entices the public to delight in grandiose artifice, deflecting the desire for novelty into areas that do not challenge the political order.

Therefore, the word that best expresses the meaning of  "directive"  in line  27  is  (D)  guiding.

Answer: D

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

7. Which one of the following pieces of evidence if it existed. would most weaken Maravall's interpretation of baroque culture?

Difficulty Level:   600-650

Explanation

To weaken Maravall's interpretation of baroque culture, we need evidence that challenges his assertion that the baroque was primarily a culture of control and containment orchestrated by the ruling class to maintain order in the face of social and economic crisis. Let's analyze each option:

(A)  This information may provide context to Maravall's perspective, but it doesn't directly address the validity of his interpretation of baroque culture.

(B)  This evidence could weaken Maravall's argument by suggesting that the nobility, rather than the monarchs, played a more significant role in shaping the cultural expression of the baroque era.

(C)  This evidence could actually support Maravall's interpretation by suggesting that baroque art was a tool for idealizing and reinforcing the power of the monarchy and aristocracy.

(D)  This evidence would significantly weaken Maravall's argument, as it suggests that baroque culture was not solely a tool of control but also a medium for expressing opposition to the ruling class.

(E)  While this information may be relevant to understanding Franco's regime, it doesn't directly address Maravall's interpretation of the baroque era. It focuses more on a later period.

Therefore, the option that would most weaken Maravall's interpretation of baroque culture is  (D)  documents indicating that many baroque-era works of art expressed opposition to the monarchy. This evidence would challenge the idea that the baroque was solely a culture of control and containment.

Answer: D

Raman109 · Answer

4. It can be inferred from the passage that Maravall regarded monarchs of the baroque era as

(A) increasingly indifferent to unfavorable public opinion - No. Opposite. Monarchs were, in fact, concerned about public opinion.

(B) concerned with the political threat posed by the aristocracy - No. Opposite. While the monarchy suppressed the bad actors, they allied more tightly with the aristocracy to maintain the rule. One example could be giving some aristocrat status in the royal palace, thus putting his skin in the game and making him more responsible to himself and the monarch.

(C) captivated by the cultural devices designed to control their subjects - This is the author's view, not Marvell's. Wrong.

(D) somewhat successful in countering the disruptive legacy of the Renaissance - Yes. They were successful.

(E) preoccupied with the goal of attaining cultural preeminence for their respective countries - Out of scope.

dhruva09 · Answer

Hi  Sajjad1994 , your explanation for Q4. does explain the circumstances surrounding the monarchs during the baroque period, but it does not explain how it was somewhat successful in countering the disruptive legacy of the Renaissance. Is there anything more to that ?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Hi dhruva09

This is not directly mentioned but we need to infer. According to Maravall, the monarchs' success wasn't in eradicating the Renaissance's disruptive ideas but in  containing, channeling, and managing them  to prevent a direct challenge to the political order. Maravall argues the system was  "not simply repressive. It was also enticing"  (lines 32-33). This is key to understanding the  "somewhat successful"  part.

Monarchs used spectacular cultural devices for example fireworks, theater, religious festivals, grand art, and architecture to create a captivating illusion of power, stability, and grandeur. The Renaissance had unleashed a powerful human desire for new ideas, criticism, and individual expression. Instead of trying to crush this desire (which would have been impossible), Baroque culture redirected it.

Monarchs first consolidated their own power by bringing the nobility to heel  ("suppressed the worst excesses of aristocratic disorder" - lines 13-14) . This created a stable, unified front among the ruling classes. The overarching goal of Baroque culture was to  "defend traditional order and values" (line 16)  against the criticism and questioning born from the Renaissance. Maravall sees this as a crucial, modern aspect. He concludes that Baroque culture emerged from " the necessity, as public opinion grew increasingly important, of manipulating opinions and feelings on a broad public scale" (lines 41-43).  I hope this is clear now.

dhruva09 · Answer

Thanks a lot  Sajjad1994 . This resolves my doubt.

To some scholars, the European baroque is not merely an aesthetic styl

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

To some scholars, the European baroque is not merely an aesthetic styl

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards