Question 2
tuyaras
I don't understand on question 2 "The passage asserts that the United States censuses of 1840 and 1890
do not provide information on which of the following?"
All Choices A,B,C are also not in the passage and the passage only said that
"about 70 percent of white men over 65 were gainfully employed;" &
"because they are silent on how many of those not employed were physically incapable of working, how many could not find work, and how many had voluntarily retired."
which is about "How many" only, not "Reason" or "Why" at all. So why the answer is C ?
Be careful with the wording of the question: "The passage
asserts that the United States censuses of 1840 and 1890 do not provide information on which of the following?" In other words, the correct answer must be something that passage specifically describes as NOT being included in the census data.
(A) and (B) weren't mentioned at all, so it would be INCORRECT to say that the passage asserts anything about those two. (To be clear: for all we know, that information IS in the census data. But the passage simply didn't talk about it, so these can't be the right answer.)
The passage does, however, make assertions about choice (C). The final paragraph starts by telling us that the data are NOT useful to test the second explanation (that older workers were retiring voluntarily). This point is explained later in the paragraph:
Quote:
Regarding the second explanation, the census data, whether for 1840 or 1890, are not helpful because
they are silent on how many of those not employed were physically incapable of working, how many could not find work, and how many had voluntarily retired. Thus, the conclusion that workers retired voluntarily cannot be proved from the census data, but neither can it be disproved.
In other words, we know that about 70 percent of white men over 65 were gainfully employed in both 1840 and 1890, but we do NOT know
why those people were not working. So choice (C) works.
I hope that helps!