OFFICIAL EXPLANATIONProject SC Butler: Sentence Correction (SC2)
For SC butler Questions Click HereQuote:
Just as the European countries of the early eighteenth century sought to exploit the resources of our continent, so too are we now attempting to extract energy and minerals from the ocean bed.
A)
Just as the European countries of the early eighteenth century sought to exploit the resources of our continent, so too are we now attempting to extract energy and minerals from the ocean bed.
B) The
European countries of the early eighteenth century sought to exploit the resources of our continent, and in a similar way
are we now attempting to extract energy and minerals from the ocean bed.
C)
Like the case of the European countries of the early eighteenth century who sought to exploit the resources of our continent,
so too are we now attempting to extract energy and minerals from the ocean bed.
D)
As in the exploitation of the resources of our continent by European countries of the early eighteenth century, are we now attempting to extract energy and minerals from the ocean bed are we now attempting to extract energy and minerals from the ocean bed..
E)
Similar to the European countries which sought in the early eighteenth century to exploit the resources of our continent are we now attempting to extract energy and minerals from the ocean bed.
Everything not in blue typeface is verbatim from Magoosh.
• Takeaways
→ Idiom: Just as X, so [too] Y
This idiom gets tested a fair bit, especially in harder questions.
You will not hear this idiom in speech, but in formal writing the idiom is quite common and is used to highlight the similarity between two events or situations.
The "too" is optional.
Items X and Y must be parallel; both are almost always subject + verb clauses, although in the case of the Y item, the verb phrase is often elided (omitted).
Just as wheat is a staple in Anglo-American countries, so too is rice in Asian countries.
→ Unusual but correct pronoun: WE
The pronoun we can be used to refer to "countries."
I do not recall an official question in which GMAC used we to stand for "countries," but I would not put such usage past GMAC writers.
(There's nothing wrong with doing so. That usage just pushes boundaries and is fairly academic.)MAGOOSH Question Explanation:
The sentence is correct as written.
The underlined portion of the sentence contains the comparison idiom
just as…so too, so check that similar items are being compared and that the idiom is used correctly.
The first item in the comparison is
European countries and the second item in the comparison is
we. These are similar items as the pronoun
we can be accurately used to refer to the noun countries.
In addition, the idiom
just as…so too is used correctly.
There appears to be no error in the original sentence, so keep choice A.
Because there is no error in the original sentence, there are no obvious repeaters to look for, so evaluate the remaining answer choices individually, looking for reasons to eliminate each.
Choice B changes the structure of the original sentence to begin with the noun
the European countries as the first item in a comparison that is referenced by the phrase
in a similar way. However, the second item of the comparison in the non-underlined portion of the sentence begins with the verb
are. This is a comparison error.
The original sentence uses the comparison idiom
just as to introduce the noun
European countries, which, coupled with
so too, correctly refers to the verb
are to introduce the pronoun
we.
Choice B lacks that introductory comparison idiom, so this is a comparison error. Eliminate choice B.
Choice C uses the [un]idiom[atic] structure
like the…so too. The correct idiom is
just as…so too, so eliminate choice C for an idiom error.
Choice D compares
the exploitation to
we, which is an incorrect comparison because these items are not similar. Eliminate choice D.
Choice E contains a comparison error [because] the noun
European countries is incorrectly compared to the verb
are. Eliminate choice E.
Choice A: Correct.
Choice B: No. The
European countries are incorrectly compared to
are. Comparison.
Choice C: No. The structure
like the…so too is an incorrect idiom. Idiom.
Choice D: No.
The exploitation is incorrectly compared to
we. Comparison.
Choice E: No.
The European countries are incorrectly compared to
are. Comparison.
The correct answer is choice A.COMMENTS
I stand with the people of Ukraine.