DrAnkita91
Not able to choose between A and E. please help if anyone comes across this question
For me too A and E was contenders. Took more than 3 mins. Not sure if my explanation helps.
The production of leather and fur for clothing is labor intensive, which means that these materials have tended to be expensive. But as fashion has moved away from these materials, their prices have dropped,
while prices of some materials that require less labor in their production and are more fashionable have risen.The situation described above conforms most closely to which one of the following generalizations?
(A) The
price of any manufactured good
depends more on how fashionable that good is
than on the materials it is made from. - WRONG. 2nd best choice here. A comparison is not the essence of the passage. But it was the general trend that happened in clothing industry, especially fashion. This one takes one aspects of the passage and moulds the conclusion such that it may look good on the first instance but it is not.
(B) It is
more important for the materials used in the manufacture of clothing to
be fashionable than it is for them to be practical. - WRONG. Neither being fashionable is essence of the passage nor the comparison.
(C) Materials that require relatively little labor in their production tend to be fashionable. - WRONG. Irrelevant. Like B only somewhat.
(D) The appearance of a manufactured good is the
only thing that determines whether it is
fashionable. - WRONG. Both red text doen't touch the conclusion at all which is about the price rise.
(E) Cultural trends
tend to be an important determinant of the prices of materials used in manufacturing. - CORRECT. POE helps. There is no comparison neither weird inference.
Answer E.