Which one of the following, if true, most seriously undermines the scientists’ contention?
Let us first analyze:
Scientists' contention: It is unlikely that the
melting process has begun since water temperatures in the polar seas are the
same today as they were a century ago.Now to weaken the argument/contention we need to attack the assumption. The assumption here is that the water temperature of polar seas is not increased hence ice melting has not begun yet.
(A) Much of the marine plant life that flourished in the polar seas will die in the event that the water temperatures rise above their present levels. -
Irrelevant (B) The overall effect of the melting process will be an increase in global sea levels.
- Trap answer. It might be true but it does not necessarily weaken the scientists' contention.(C) The mean air temperature above both land and water in the polar regions has not varied significantly over the past 100 years.
-Irrelevant(D) The temperature of water that contains melting ice tends to remain constant until all of the ice in the ice-and-water mixture has melted. -
Answer, as it is directly attacking the scientists' contention.
(E) The mean temperature of ocean waters near the equator has remained constant over the past 100 years.
-Irrelevant
Correct answer: D