People who do well in the sled pull competition have tremendous upper body strength. Caleb has tremendous upper body strength. Therefore, Caleb performed well in the sled pull competition.
Which one of the following contains the same reasoning that is presented in the passage?
(A) People who are anemic cannot donate blood. Mary donates blood regularly. Therefore, she must not be anemic.
IncorrectX happen so Y not happen; Y happen, so X must not happen;
not parallel
(B)
People who swim competitively are thin and muscular. Ben is thin and muscular Therefore, Ben is a competitive swimmer.
CorrectX happen because Y happen; Y happen, so X must be happen;
parallel
(C) People who volunteer at the trauma center must handle being on their feet all day. Casey is a frequent volunteer at the trauma center. Therefore, he must handle being on his feet all day.
IncorrectX happen because Y happen; X happen, so y must be happen;
not parallel
(D) People who are overly sensitive to the cold cannot work at the Arctic substation. John is overly sensitive to the cold. Therefore John cannot work at the Arctic substation.
IncorrectX happen so Y not happen; X happen, so Y must not happen;
not parallel
(E) People who have ulcers cannot eat spicy hot food. Kevin has recurrent ulcers. Therefore Kevin is on a bland diet.
IncorrectX happen so Y not happen; X happen, so Y must not happen;
not parallel