Political scientist: The economies of a number of European countries

Question

Political scientist: The economies of a number of European countries are currently in severe difficulty. Germany is the only neighboring country that has the resources to resuscitate these economies. Therefore, Germany should begin aiding these economically troubled countries.

Which one of the following principles most helps to justify the political scientist’s reasoning?

(A) Any nation that alone has an obligation to economically resuscitate neighboring countries ought to be the only nation to provide any economic aid.

(B) Any nation that alone has the capacity to economically resuscitate neighboring countries should exercise that capacity.

(C) Any nation that can afford to give economic aid to just a few other nations ought to aid just those few.

(D) Only nations that alone have the capacity to economically resuscitate neighboring countries should exercise that capacity.

(E) Only nations that can afford to give economic aid to just a few other nations ought to aid just those few.

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

EXPLANATION FROM Fox LSAT

The magic naughty word here is “should.” I’m sorry, political scientist, but you are  not  the boss of Germany so you do  not  get to say what Germany should or should not do. If Germany wishes to continue making cool cars, yodeling, drinking lots of beer, and growing ridiculous beards and mustaches, then that is damn well what Germany gets to do. Don’t be bossy.

We’re asked to “justify” the political scientist’s reasoning, which means pretend this guy is your client: "He's an idiot but I've got to try to help him prove his case because he paid me a lot of money.” So we need to find a principle that  would  make the political scientist the boss of Germany. Our evidence is that Germany’s neighbors are in “severe economic difficulty,” and that Germany is the only neighboring country that has the ability to do anything about it. How do we get from that evidence to, “Therefore Germany should step in”?

Perfect answers would be:

“If you’re the only neighbor that can help, then you should help.”
or 
  “If your neighbor is in trouble, then you should help.”

Either of those would directly connect the evidence to the desired conclusion. Let’s see.

A) Nah. The point isn’t whether Germany should fulfill an obligation it already has, the point is whether Germany has that obligation in the first place. This is a trap.

B) Yep. This one says, “If you’re the only neighbor that can help, then you should help.” I am in deep, deep love with this answer.

C) Nah. This is tricky, but it’s out because it may or may not apply to Germany. Suppose Germany is so rich that it could, if it wanted to, provide aid to every nation in the world? If that’s true (which we don’t know), then this rule wouldn’t force Germany to do anything at all. B was definitely better, because it didn’t contain an escape hatch.

D) The word “only” makes this wrong, because “only” indicates a necessary condition. This answer says, “If you’re going to provide help, then you better be the only nation that has the capacity to do so.” That would mean that Germany is eligible to provide help (since it’s the only neighbor who can) but it still wouldn’t mean that Germany  should  do so. We needed something that would force Germany to do something, not make them  eligible  to do something. If you remove the word “only” from the beginning of this answer choice, it would definitely be correct.

E) This is wrong for both the reason we discussed in C and the reason we discussed in D.

This question is really easy for somebody with a good amount of LSAT experience and training, but probably really confusing if you’re just starting out. Let me know if you need more help or examples with this one. Our answer is B.

REALMAREZ · Answer

B 
Honestly I do not like this kind of S questions.

Political scientist: The economies of a number of European countries are currently in severe difficulty. Germany is the only neighboring country that has the resources to resuscitate these economies. Therefore, Germany should begin aiding these economically troubled countries.

Which one of the following principles most helps to justify the political scientist’s reasoning?

(A) Any nation that alone has an obligation to economically resuscitate neighboring countries ought to be the only nation to provide any economic aid. --  Germany is the only one but here it says Germany should not be the only one

(B) Any nation that alone has the capacity to economically resuscitate neighboring countries should exercise that capacity.--  Correct

(C) Any nation that can afford to give economic aid to just a few other nations ought to aid just  those few .--  Nahh, who talks about number of nations?

(D)  Only  nations that alone have the capacity to economically resuscitate neighboring countries should exercise that capacity. --  The author is not arguing that Germany should be the only nation to provide aid, but that there is an obligation for Germany to do so for its neighbors.

(E)  Only  nations that can afford to give economic aid to just a  few other nations  ought to aid just those few. --  Again, see C

unraveled · Answer

Political scientist: The economies of a number of European countries are currently in severe difficulty. Germany is the only neighboring country that has the resources to resuscitate these economies. Therefore, Germany should begin aiding these economically troubled countries.

Which one of the following principles most helps to justify the political scientist’s reasoning?

(A) Any nation that alone has an  obligation  to economically resuscitate neighboring countries ought to be the only nation to provide any economic aid. - WRONG. Others can also do that if there's no obligation.

(B) Any nation that alone has the capacity to economically resuscitate neighboring countries should exercise that capacity. - CORRECT. POE helps.

(C) Any nation that can  afford to give economic aid  to just a few other nations ought to aid  just those few . - WRONG. "Afford" adds a different colour to the passage besides "just those few" too does that.

(D)  Only nations  that alone have the capacity to economically resuscitate neighboring countries should exercise that capacity. - WRONG. Not necessarily true. Others too can do that.

(E)  Only nations  that can  afford  to give economic aid to  just a few other nations  ought to aid just those few. - WRONG. Suffers from all the problem that all other choices have.

Answer B.

Political scientist: The economies of a number of European countries

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

Political scientist: The economies of a number of European countries

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards