Bunuel
The morning after a snowstorm had left a uniform amount of snow on each driveway on the block, Homeowner R turned on his automatic driveway heater to help melt the snow away. The snow on this homeowner's driveway melted quickly because the automatic driveway heater is designed to pump warm water into pipes that are situated just below the surface of the driveway.
Which of the following, if true, most seriously jeopardizes the validity of the explanation for the speed with which the snow melted on the driveway belonging to Homeowner R?
A) The same snowstorm mentioned above left much less snow on the driveways of homeowners in a neighboring town, and the snow there melted quickly without the use of automatic driveway heaters.
B) Even though Homeowner S, who lives on the same block as Homeowner R, made no effort to melt the snow on his driveway, the snow on Homeowner S's driveway melted just as fast as the snow melted on the driveway with the automatic heater.
C) Homeowner T, who lives on the same block as Homeowner R, shovels the snow off of his driveway rather than investing in an automatic driveway heater.
D) Automatic driveway heaters are expensive to install since they require that the existing driveway be completely removed in order to install the necessary pipes.
E) The automatic driveway heater used by Homeowner R operates with its own water heater so that it can work efficiently even when people in the house are using warm water to take showers, to do the laundry, or for other uses.
Snow storm has led to UNIFORM AMOUNT OF SNOW on each driveway. Homeowner R used electric heater to melt the snow away. The electric heater pumps hot water to melt snow.
We need to WEAKEN this argument.
Something else, must have led to the melting of snow. Or else the snow would have melted naturally.
Let’s look into the options.
A) The same snowstorm mentioned above left much less snow on the driveways of homeowners in a neighboring town, and the snow there melted quickly without the use of automatic driveway heaters.
It’s contradicting the fact mentioned in the question stem - uniform snow fall. Hence, out of scope.
B) Even though Homeowner S, who lives on the same block as Homeowner R, made no effort to melt the snow on his driveway, the snow on Homeowner S's driveway melted just as fast as the snow melted on the driveway with the automatic heater.A comparison is made here among two homeowners S and R. Mentioning S melted
just as fast as R.
C) Homeowner T, who lives on the same block as Homeowner R, shovels the snow off of his driveway rather than investing in an automatic driveway heater.
Melting and Shoveling are different aspect. Hence, out of scope.
D) Automatic driveway heaters are expensive to install since they require that the existing driveway be completely removed in order to install the necessary pipes.
Out of scope.
E) The automatic driveway heater used by Homeowner R operates with its own water heater so that it can work efficiently even when people in the house are using warm water to take showers, to do the laundry, or for other uses.
This is not a weaken statement. But, it is a strengthener. Hence not correct.
Hence,
Option B