ExpertsGlobal5
The Peregrine Foundation is a private, non-profit leukemia research institute. In the last ten years, the foundation has received an increased amount of donations, and the cost of conducting research has decreased. Yet, the quality of research produced by the foundation has fallen. Meanwhile, the quality of research conducted by most other leukemia-research organizations has risen. Clearly, over the past ten years, The Peregrine Foundation must have become a self-serving and wasteful organization.
Which of the following, if true, would most seriously weaken the conclusion reached in the passage?
A. Many other private, non-profit organizations involved in leukemia research provide financial relief to leukemia patients, in addition to conducting research.
B. Ten years ago, the quality of research produced by The Peregrine Foundation was better than that of other private, non-profit organizations involved in leukemia research.
C. The average salaries of scientists and medical professionals employed by The Peregrine Foundation are slightly higher than those of doctors and scientists employed by other private, non-profit organizations involved in leukemia research.
D. Over the past ten years, the percentage of the donations received by The Peregrine Foundation spent on research has risen, while the percentage spent on the management of the foundation has fallen.
E. Over the past ten years, the increase in the absolute amount of donations received by The Peregrine Foundation has averaged approximately five percent more than the local rate of inflation.
|
This Daily Butler Question was provided by
Experts' Global
|
|
Sponsored
|
|
|
The passage is about the peregrine foundation (PF) , which is non profit leukemia research institute.
During the last ten years, the donations has increased, the cost of research has decreased, and the quality of research publications has decreased.
During the same time, the quality of research published by other foundations has shown an increase during the same period.
So, the conclusion is PF is a self serving and wasteful organisation.
We need to weaken this conclusion.
A. Many other private, non-profit organizations involved in leukemia research provide financial relief to leukemia patients, in addition to conducting research.
This is out of scope option. As , this doesn’t address the conclusion. Moreover, we are concerned with the particular organisation PF only. Hence, Wrong.
B. Ten years ago, the quality of research produced by The Peregrine Foundation was better than that of other private, non-profit organizations involved in leukemia research.
We are not speaking about the past. We are speaking about what happened in this ten years. Hence, Wrong.
C. The average salaries of scientists and medical professionals employed by The Peregrine Foundation are slightly higher than those of doctors and scientists employed by other private, non-profit organizations involved in leukemia research.
If the average salaries of the scientists and medical professionals employed by PF is high, then we can logically correlate the output of their work to be high. But, this is contradictory to the fact. Hence, Wrong.
D. Over the past ten years, the percentage of the donations received by The Peregrine Foundation spent on research has risen, while the percentage spent on the management of the foundation has fallen.This option is the correct answer. This says the % of the donations received by PF has risen, and the amount spent on research is also risen. So, the amount spent on management is less, so the major contribution is done for the welfare of the luekemia patients. So, this projects the view that the PF is not self serving, and is concerned with non profit aspects.
E. Over the past ten years, the increase in the absolute amount of donations received by The Peregrine Foundation has averaged approximately five percent more than the local rate of inflation.
The inflation aspect is not discussed in the passsge. But a neutral aspect. So, this doesn’t necessarily address the conclusion. Hence, irrelevant option. Wrong.
Option D