The Japanese Gardens' coral reef, situated in the western tip of the

Question

The Japanese Gardens' coral reef, situated in the western tip of the Arabian Peninsula, is considered one of the most beautiful reefs on earth, contains many fish which are indigenous to it, and exhibits a unique construction of the subterranean landscape. However, it is not among the list of the 50 most visited diving areas.

All of the following may help resolve the seeming discrepancy above EXCEPT:

A. Most of the world's divers are from the Americas, over 7000 miles away from the Arabian Peninsula.

B. Due to severe underwater currents throughout most of the year, the Japanese Gardens can only be accessed during two months of the year.

C. Diving in the Japanese Gardens requires a high level of expertise.

D. While the vast majority of the diving areas on the 50 most visited diving areas' list are accessible from the beach, the Japanese gardens can only be accessed from a boat.

E. As in many of the diving areas on the 50 most visited diving areas' list, one must train for at least two weeks before one can dive in the Japanese Gardens.

This is a  CR Butler Question

Check the links to other Butler Projects:
 
  Data Sufficiency Butler  
  Problem Solving Butler  
  Reading Comprehension Butler

counterclash1 · Answer

CORRECT ANSWER : E

The Paradox:  Japanese Gardens is one of the most beautiful and unique coral reefs on earth, yet it fails to rank among the top 50 most visited diving locations.
To resolve this paradox, an option must introduce a  barrier  or  differentiating factor  that keeps diver volume low relative to top-ranked spots.

Option A: Introduces a distance barrier (location relative to target market). 
 Option B: Introduces a time constraint barrier (2-month annual window). 
 Option C: Introduces a skill ceiling barrier (expert divers only). 
 Option D: Introduces a logistical barrier (boat access vs. beach access). 
  Option E (Correct):  Explicitly states that "many of the diving areas on the 50 most visited list" share this exact requirement. Because this constraint applies to both Japanese Gardens and the top-performing sites, it cannot explain the difference in popularity.

dhart · Answer

A. Most of the world’s divers are from the Americas, over 7000 miles away from the Arabian Peninsula.
So the geography is the issue, divers may be visit nearby diving areas in Americas so 50 most vositied is in americas

B. Due to severe underwater currents throughout most of the year, the Japanese Gardens can only be accessed during two months of the year.
So cliamte is the issue , most of the year it's inaccessible , hence less ppl visit

C. Diving in the Japanese Gardens requires a high level of expertise.
Expertise req is very high , not many ppl have that experience so less visited

D. While the vast majority of the diving areas on the 50 most visited diving areas’ list are accessible from the beach, the Japanese gardens can only be accessed from a boat.
Accesibility isn't easy, like directly from the beach.

E. As in many of the diving areas on the 50 most visited diving areas’ list, one must train for at least two weeks before one can dive in the Japanese Gardens.
 only requiremnt is 2 weeks prior training like other 50 most visited places , then why not , this looks like exception

Minka99 · Answer

The only choice which seemed not to explain the paradox, is  E .

This is the only answer which draws on similarities between the diving locations instead of differentiating between the Japanese Gardens and the top 50 destinations.

Vivek1707 · Answer

A. Being 7,000+ miles away makes the reef less accessible to most divers, so this could explain the low visits.
B. Only being accessible for two months a year would obviously limit the number of visitors.
C. If diving there requires advanced skills, that could reduce the number of people who can visit.
D. Needing a boat makes the site less convenient than the many beach-accessible sites, so this could explain the discrepancy.
E. Yes, This doesn't explain anything because the other top diving sites have the same training requirement. So it doesn't distinguish Japanese Gardens from the popular sites.

Bunuel · Answer

OFFICIAL EXPLANATION

The Japanese Gardens' coral reef, situated in the western tip of the Arabian Peninsula, is considered one of the most beautiful reefs on earth, contains many fish which are indigenous to it, and exhibits a unique construction of the subterranean landscape. However, it is not among the list of the 50 most visited diving areas.

All of the following may help resolve the seeming discrepancy above EXCEPT:

A. Most of the world's divers are from the Americas, over 7000 miles away from the Arabian Peninsula.

Incorrect.

This is a Paradox question, so it is made up of premises only; you need to find a new premise which best resolves the apparent discrepancy between the existing premises:

Premise A: The Japanese' Gardens coral reef is a really cool place to go scuba diving.
✖
Premise B: It isn't one of the 50 most visited diving areas.

Resolving Premise: ?

If most of the divers come from North and South America and the place in question is in the Arabian Peninsula, the distance between the two may make it a less likely choice, and so can help resolve the apparent discrepancy.

B. Due to severe underwater currents throughout most of the year, the Japanese Gardens can only be accessed during two months of the year.

Incorrect.

If one can only go to the Japanese Gardens during two months of the year, there is less of a chance that he or she will go there. This definitely helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy.

C. Diving in the Japanese Gardens requires a high level of expertise.

Incorrect.

If only highly experienced divers can dive in a diving resort, all the less experienced divers will have to dive elsewhere. This helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy between the many attractions of the resort and the relatively few visitors it receives.

D. While the vast majority of the diving areas on the 50 most visited diving areas' list are accessible from the beach, the Japanese gardens can only be accessed from a boat.

Incorrect.

Accessibility can affect the decision to dive in a specific resort. We are hinted of this by the fact that almost all of the primary diving areas can be reached from the shore. This helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy between the many attractions of the resort and the relatively few visitors it receives.

E. As in many of the diving areas on the 50 most visited diving areas' list, one must train for at least two weeks before one can dive in the Japanese Gardens.

If many of the diving areas require at least two weeks of training, the fact that the Japanese Gardens also requires training does not help to explain why other sites were chosen over it by most divers. This answer choice does not help resolve the paradox and is therefore the correct one.

TheAdmissionHub · Answer

The Japanese Gardens' coral reef, situated in the western tip of the Arabian Peninsula, is considered one of the most beautiful reefs on earth, contains many fish which are indigenous to it, and exhibits a unique construction of the subterranean landscape. However, it is not among the list of the 50 most visited diving areas.
 Premise : The Japanese Gardens' coral reef, situated in the western tip of the Arabian Peninsula, is considered one of the most beautiful reefs on earth, contains many fish which are indigenous to it, and exhibits a unique construction of the subterranean landscape
 Conclusion : However, it is not among the list of the 50 most visited diving areas.

All of the following may help resolve the seeming discrepancy above EXCEPT:
  
 A. Most of the world's divers are from the Americas, over 7000 miles away from the Arabian Peninsula.
 Wrong:  proximity would draw people diving in this place, but as most divers are far away they they cannot dive there and this explains why despite being among the most beautuful reefs on earth, it’s not among the list of the 50 most visited diving diving areas.
 
 B. Due to severe underwater currents throughout most of the year, the Japanese Gardens can only be accessed during two months of the year.
 Wrong:  this explains the paradox as well because divers or just average people don’t dive there ad it’s difficult, dangerous maybe.
 
 C. Diving in the Japanese Gardens requires a high level of expertise.
 Wrong:  just experts would be suitable for diving in these areas; average people don’t dive there because they cant, they are not prepared for that.
 
 D. While the vast majority of the diving areas on the 50 most visited diving areas' list are accessible from the beach, the Japanese gardens can only be accessed from a boat.
 Wrong:  It’s more difficult to be reached, that’s why fewer people dive there.
 
 E. As in many of the diving areas on the 50 most visited diving areas' list, one must train for at least two weeks before one can dive in the Japanese Gardens.
 Correct:  it says that there are no differences between these reefs and others, so it doesn’t explain why despite being among the most beautuful reefs on earth, it’s not among the list of the 50 most visited diving diving areas.

The Japanese Gardens' coral reef, situated in the western tip of the

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

The Japanese Gardens' coral reef, situated in the western tip of the

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards