In a roomful of spies, some spies carry Argentinian passports, some ca

Question

In a roomful of spies, some spies carry Argentinian passports, some carry Bolivian passports, and some carry Chilean passports. Every spy carries at least one passport, no spy carries more than one passport from a given country, and only one spy carries passports from all three countries. The number of spies who carry Bolivian passports is two more than the number of spies who carry Argentinian passports, two less than the number of spies who carry Chilean passports, twice the number of spies who carry both Bolivian and Chilean passports, and half the total number of spies in the room. The number of spies who carry both Argentinian and Bolivian passports is two more than the number of spies who carry both Argentinian and Chilean passports and two less than the number of spies who carry both Bolivian and Chilean passports. If a spy is selected at random, what is the probability that he will carry an Argentinian passport?

(A) 2/9
(B) 13/57
(C) 6/23
(D) 3/7
(E) 1/2

Kudos for a correct solution.

(A) 2/9
(B) 13/57
(C) 6/23
(D) 3/7
(E) 1/2

Kudos for a correct  solution .

goldfinchmonster · Answer

Hi Bunuel, 
 I wanted to know whether GMAT can present such a big question. Solving it will certainly take more than 3-4 mins.

Bunuel · Answer

Yes, you want see such question on the GMAT. It's Knewton Brutal Challenge question. Good for practice though.

VenoMfTw · Answer

IMO : D

Consider the following Venn Diagram

Attachment:

Capture.JPG [ 18.03 KiB | Viewed 4207 times ]

No. of ppl carrying all 3 passports = 1
No. of ppl carrying none = 0

number of spies who carry Bolivian passports = two more than the number of spies who carry Argentinian passports
b+d+f+1 = a+d+e+1+2
b+f = a+e+2 --Eq (i)

number of spies who carry Bolivian passports = two less than the number of spies who carry Chilean passports
b+d+f+1 = c+e+f+1-2
b+d = c+e-2 --Eq (ii)

number of spies who carry Bolivian passports = twice the number of spies who carry both Bolivian and Chilean passports
b+d+f+1 = 2(f+1)
b+d = f+1 --Eq (iii)

number of spies who carry Bolivian passports = half the total number of spies in the room
b+d+f+1 = 1/2(a+b+c+d+e+f+1)
b+d+f+1 = a+e+c --Eq (iv)

number of spies who carry both Argentinian and Bolivian passports = two more than the number of spies who carry both Argentinian and Chilean passports
d+1 = e+1 +2
d=e+2 -- Eq (v)

number of spies who carry both Argentinian and Bolivian passports = two less than the number of spies who carry both Bolivian and Chilean passports
d+1 = f+1 -2
d = f-2 Eq (vi)

From (v) & (vi)
e+4 = f --(vii)

From (vi) & (iii)
b+f-2 = f+1
b=3

From (ii) & (iii) & (vii)
b+d = c+e-2 && b+d = f+1
f+1 = c+e-2
e+4+1 = c+e-2
c=7

From (i) & (iv)
b+f = a+e+2 && b+d+f+1 = a+e+c
a+e+2+d+1 = a+e+c
d+3=c
d=4

Sub b=3, d=4, c=7 in (ii)
e=2

From (vii)
f=6

sub b=3. c=7, d=4, e=2 , f=6 in (i)
b+f = a+e+2
9 = a+4
a=5

On solving these equations we end with
a = 5, b = 3, c = 7, d = 4, e = 2, f = 6

Prob = \(\frac{a+d+e+1}{Total}\)
= \(\frac{12}{28}\)
= \(\frac{3}{7}\)

Marchewski · Answer

IMO: D - 3/7

The total number of spies is

T = A + B + C - (AB + AC + BC) + 1 (Spy with all three passports) - 0 (Spy without any of the passports)

Now,

B = A + 2 = C - 2 = 2BC = 0.5T 
AB = AC + 2 = BC - 2

Thus,

T = B - 2 + B + B + 2 - (BC - 2 + BC - 4 + BC) + 1
T = 3B - (1.5B - 6) + 1 = 1.5B + 7

2B = 1.5B + 7

B=14, A=12, C=16, BC=7, AB=5, AC=3, T=28

A/T=12/28=3/7

Bambaruush · Answer

I can not attach pic. So I am using just labels. Let

T - total

AB - A and B holder
AC - A and C holder
BC - B and C holder

a - only A holder
b - only B holder
c - only C holder.

Given:

A+2=B
C-2=B
T=2B
AB=AC+2
AB=BC-2

From these we can derive:

A+4=C
AC+4=BC

Further, if you look at the pic and differences between the numbers you will find out

a=b+2
c=b+4
c=a+2 or you can derive these by making more substitutions.

So, if you make substitution for all the numbers and express the whole table with one variable a, it will be like this.

AB=a-1
BC=a+1
AC=a-3 , in order to make it positive integer a must be more than equal 4.

Now, we can easily estimate following:

A=3a-3
B=3a-1
C=3a+1

There is a problem here. a can be any number more than equal 4 and all these number will satisfy the whole relations. I started substitution from 4.

a=4, A=9, B=11, C=13. Hence A/2B=9/22
a=5, A=12, B=14, C=16. Hence A/2B=3/7 This is in the answer choices.
a=6, A=15, B=17, C=19. Hence A/2B=15/34
a=7, A=18, B=20, C=22. Hence A/2B=9/20
a=100, A=297, B=299, C=301. Hence blaa blaa blaa

Is there max limit for a? I couldn't find :cry:

VenoMfTw · Answer

Hi,
You have considered B = A+2 for (The number of spies who carry Bolivian passports is two more than the number of spies who carry Argentinian passports) statement.
The question didn't say who carry only Bolivian passports right? Correct me if i am wrong.

Regards,
Rakesh

kunal555 · Answer

This is going to be a big explanation. It is Better to do the question with Venn diagram.
Let the number of only Argentinian spies be x
the number of only Bolivian spies be y
the number of only Chilean spies be z
the number of only Argentinian and Chilean spies be a
the number of only Argentinian and Bolivian spies be b 
the number of only Chilean and Bolivian spies be c
the number of spies who carry all 3 passports is 1.

the probability that the spy selected at random will carry Argentinian passport will be

\frac{(x+a+b+1)}{(x+y+z+a+b+c+1)}

Now, moving on to the conditions

1) The number of spies who carry Bolivian passports is two more than the number of spies who carry Argentinian passports
 y+b+c+1 = x+a+b+1+2
or y+c=x+a+2
 
2) The number of spies who carry Bolivian passports is two less than the number of spies who carry Chilean passports
 y+b+c+1 =z+c+a+1-2
or y+b=z+a-2
 
3) The number of spies who carry Bolivian passports is twice the number of spies who carry both Bolivian and Chilean passports
 y+b+c+1 = 2(c+1)
or y+b = c+1

4) The number of spies who carry Bolivian passports is half the total number of spies in the room
 y+b+c+1 = 1/2(x+y+z+a+b+c+1)
or 2y+2b+2c+2 = x+y+z+a+b+c+1
or y+b+c+1= x+z+a

5) The number of spies who carry both Argentinian and Bolivian passports is two more than the number of spies who carry both Argentinian and Chilean passports
 b+1 = a+1+2
or b=a+2
or a=b-2

6) The number of spies who carry both Argentinian and Bolivian passports is two less than the number of spies who carry both Bolivian and Chilean passports
 b+1=c+1-2
or b=c-2
or c= b+2

Now,
putting the value of c in statement 3)

y+b= b+2+1
or  y = 3

putting the value of a and c (in terms of b from statements 5 & 6 respectively) and y in statement 1)
 3+b+2= x+b
or  x = 5

putting value of a (in terms of b from statement 5) and y in statement 2)
 3+b= z+b-4
or  z = 7

putting values of x,y,z,a and c in statement 4)

3+b+b+2+1=5+7+b-2
or 2b+6 = b+10
or  b = 4

putting this value of b in statement 5)

a=b-2
or  a = 2

putting this value of b in statement 6)

c=b+2
or  c = 6

so the probability will be

\frac{(x+a+b+1)}{(x+y+z+a+b+c+1)}  =  \frac{(5+2+4+1)}{(5+3+7+2+4+6+1)}  =  \frac{12}{28} =

\frac{3}{7}

Answer:- D

Bambaruush · Answer

Oh my God, careless me. Missed the fact that the number of spies who carry Bolivian passports is twice the number of spies who carry both Bolivian and Chilean passports. That is why I was struggling to find definite values. :roll:

Marchewski · Answer

Sorry for my slow reponse. For the formula I used it is not necessecary to know the number of people who only carry Bolivian passports. 
B is just the number of spies that have Bolivian passports - no matter if they have more than just this one passport. 
Considering your Venn B = b + d + f + 1 = A + 2.

KarishmaB · Answer

The question is long but not hard. Let's try to stick with one variable. Note: "The number of spies who carry Bolivian passports is two more..., two less ..., twice ..., and half the total number of spies in the room. This is an interesting relation. Let's assume total number of spies = N. Every spy has at least one passport. Now from the given information, you can draw this venn diagram: Sets.jpg Total = n(A) + n(B) + n(C) - n(A and B) - n(B and C) - n(C and A) + n(A and B and C) N = (N/2 -2) +N/2 + (N/2 + 2) - (N/4 - 2) - N/4 - (N/4 - 4) + 1 N = 28 n(A) = 12 Required Probability = 12/28 = 3/7

rajarshee · Answer

You don't need to solve anything to arrive at the answer. Probability of picking up a spy with Bolivian passport = 1/2
And the number of spies who hold Argentinian passport is just 2 less than that of spies who hold Bolivian passports. So the probability here will be little less than 1/2 but not a lot. 3/7 is the only option that fits. However if the options were any closer you'll have to solve for the answer.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

In a roomful of spies, some spies carry Argentinian passports, some ca

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

In a roomful of spies, some spies carry Argentinian passports, some ca

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards