Water is pumped in and out of a tank using an inlet and outlet pipe

Question

Water is pumped in and out of a tank using an inlet and outlet pipe respectively. If the tank is initially empty, how much time will it take to fill up the tank, when both the pipes are opened simultaneously?

I. The inlet pipe takes 20 minutes to fill the empty tank and the outlet pipe take 60 minutes to empty a full tank.
II. The amount of water the tank can hold is 100 gallons.

LevanKhukhunashvili · Accepted Answer

To solve the problem we need rates for both A and B

1 stm - exactly gives what we want.  Suff 
We dont need further calculations, but if you are "Quantworm":
A fills  \frac{1}{20}  th of the tank in 1 minute,
B empties  \frac{1}{60}  th of the tank in 1 minute,
So in 1 minute the tank is filled by  \frac{1}{20} - \frac{1}{60} = \frac{1}{30}  in 1 minute
To fill the tank when both pipes are open 30 minutes are required;

Use LCM method (my favorite)
Assume that the tank's capacity is 60 liters
A can fill 3 liters in 1 minute
B can empty 1 liter per minute
So in 1 minute, 2 liters are added to the tank and to fill 60-liter tank 30 minutes are required

2 stm - In this case, the capacity is redundant and is introduced to concern us;  insuff

IMO
Ans:  A

MSIMBA · Answer

I. The inlet pipe takes 20 minutes to fill the empty tank and the outlet pipe take 0 minutes to empty a full tank.

1 is sufficient as 1/20-1/60 = 1/30 clearly explains the total time to fill up tank again

CrackverbalGMAT · Answer

To calculate the time taken to complete the work, we need the individual rates of the inlet and outlet pipes. 
On the other hand, if we know the quantum of work to be done, we will not be able to calculate the time required, since we do not know the rates of working of the pipes.

From statement I alone, we know that the inlet pipe takes 20 minutes to fill an empty tank and the outlet pipe takes 60 minutes to empty a full tank. 
Let the capacity of the tank be 60 litres (which is the LCM of 20 and 60), which also represents the work to be done. This means,

Rate of inlet pipe =  \frac{Work done}{Time taken}  =  \frac{60}{20}  = 3 litres per hour

Rate of outlet pipe =  \frac{Work done}{Time taken}  =  \frac{60}{60}  = -1 litre per hour (negative because it's the outlet pipe)

Therefore, when both of them are opened simultaneously, combined rate = 2 litres per hour. Since we know the combined rate, we can calculate the time taken by them, when working together. 
Statement I alone is sufficient. Answer options can be A or D. Options B, C and E can be eliminated.

From statement II alone, we only know the capacity of the tank. From what you saw above, it will not be hard to understand that knowing the capacity alone will not help you find the rates. Hence, it wont be possible to calculate the time taken by them working together. 
Statement II is insufficient.

The correct answer option is A.

Hope this helps!

TheNightKing · Answer

I guess I am not able to think straight because of the person sitting next to me who is continuously talking.
Here is my doubt:
Why is the size of the tank not relevant ?
So Yeah we assume the capacity to be 60 and get inlet pipe work as +3 and outlet as -1 Which gives us a result of 30 minutes. But what if the size of the tank is 600. We get 300 minutes which is 5 hours.
What am I missing?

ccooley · Answer

To see what you missed, work through the full problem with your second example of a size 600 tank.

If the tank has a capacity of 600, then the inlet pipe fills it at a rate of 600 units / 20 minutes = 30 units per minute, and the outlet pipe empties it at a rate of 600 units / 60 minutes = 10 units per minute.

Therefore, the net change is +20 units per minute.

So, to fill the entire thing, it will take 600 units / (20 units per minute) = 30 minutes. That's the same as with a size 60 tank.

----

Now, try it with yet another different size tank. What if the size of the tank is 300 instead of 600? The inlet pipe fills 300 units in 20 minutes, so that's 15 units per minute. The outlet pipe empties 300 units in 60 minutes, so that's 5 units per minute. In total, we're at +10 units per minute. Filling the whole thing will take 300 units / (10 units per minute) = 30 minutes. Same value.

----

And, with a variable: If the size of the tank is T units, the inlet pipe fills it at T/20 units per minute, and the outlet pipe empties it at T/60 units per minute. The net increase is T/20 - T/60 = 3T/60 - T/60 = 2T/60 = T/30 units per minute.

To fill a tank of size T, at T/30 units per minute, takes T/(T/30) = 30 minutes, no matter what T is. The reason T doesn't matter is that it cancels out in this solution!

TheNightKing · Answer

ccooley 
Thank you for your detailed explanation.
I knew I am missing something. Thank you!

masonjones5711 · Answer

To fill up the tank with both pipes open simultaneously, you need to consider the net inflow rate. The inlet pipe fills 1/20 of the tank per minute, and the outlet pipe empties 1/60 of the tank per minute. So, the net inflow rate is 1/20 - 1/60 = 1/30 of the tank per minute.

To fill the entire 100-gallon tank, it will take 100 / (1/30) = 3000 minutes.

Water is pumped in and out of a tank using an inlet and outlet pipe

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

Water is pumped in and out of a tank using an inlet and outlet pipe

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards