Quote from Kaplan GMAT Premier 2012-2013 in the Problem Solving section related to the Picking Numbers strategy;
"The advice to use 0 and 1 is among the most commonly offered
bad advice out there. Though 0 and 1 have properties that can complicate some problems, those same properties can radically simplify others. Don't be scared out of using two of the most powerful and manageable numbers in all of math!". It goes on to confirm that picking numbers is a valid approach where there are "(2) Variables in the answer choices".
Quote from Kaplan Lesson on Demand video number 14, 'Picking Numbers - Variables in the Answer Choices' video - free with Premier 2012-2013;
"In these types of questions you want avoid picking 1 or zero because they tend to make multiple answer choices the same thing."
So I guess they are right that this advice is common - they give it...