amitagia
I have admits from both schools with substantial scholarship. At this point Fisher is only marginally cheaper so money isn't exactly the key differentiator.
I wish to go into consulting eventually but neither Fisher nor ND are core consulting schools ! Would like to know what some of you would do in my situation!
Brand wise, ND is going to be the better choice. Consulting out of both for MBB will be tough. Definitely consider taking another year to improve your resume and reapply if you are set on MBB, but ND is a good school with a great alumni base. Look closer at their career report, they state that McKinsey, Deloitte, Huron, FIT, etc all hire there, so there are options.
I would choose ND personally based on brand, reputation, and strength of alumni. OSU is a great school, but outside of the Midwest, I'm not sure of the perception. So when looking at where you want to be after, that's something to consider as well.