Situation: I am in the very lucky position of having been accepted to Wharton and Booth, but I am waiting on a decision from MIT Sloan. I visited both Wharton and Sloan and got a slightly better feeling from Sloan than Wharton. I was not able to visit Booth.
Background: 40-year-old SEAL Officer transitioning out of active duty in July of 2026. Intend to use an Executive MBA program to facilitate my transition. No previous business experience. Undergraduate degree in Mechanical Engineering.
Test Score: Executive Assessment: 161
Post MBA Goal: Uncertain, but I am very interested in clean/renewable energy generation and storage. I believe a role in operations at a new/start-up company would be a good fit to leverage my previous work/leadership experience in high-pressure organizations and my interest/undergraduate background in technology.
Wharton:
Pros:
• Brand Recognition
• Alumni support network
• Lodging and meals included
• Geographically convenient to commute to from D.C.
• Broad breadth of experience in education and cohort (tech, finance, real-estate, etc) which would be useful in not getting pigeon holed in an area if I find my interests shift once I start.
Cons:
• Wharton is an outstanding institution but MIT seems to have a better reputation in tech where a lot of my interests lie.
• Perception is that Wharton is more finance centric.
• Has GI Bill and Yellow Ribbon but not full coverage resulting in a net cost to me of ~$30k.
• Philly isn’t the nicest city these days.
• Deposit due 11JAN24 which is before MIT Sloan decision date
Booth:
Pros:
• Brand Recognition
• Global New Venture Challenge seems like the exact type of program I would want to participate in.
• Full GI Bill and Yellow Ribbon coverage so no cost to me.
• Chicago is a great city
Cons:
• Lodging and meals not included
• More geographically challenging to travel to from D.C. than Wharton
• Deposit due 05JAN24 which is before MIT Sloan decision date
MIT Sloan:
Pros:
• MIT writ large is world renowned for tech
• Opportunity to work with engineers at MIT who are developing new tech and bring it to market
• Full GI Bill and Yellow Ribbon coverage so no cost to me.
• Possibly relocating to Boston after the Navy
• Boston is a great city
Cons:
•
Late decision (Feb 24) for Sloan will necessitate a deposit at Wharton ($2500) or Booth ($5000) to hold a spot in the event I’m not admitted• Sloan specifically is perhaps less well known for MBA programs outside of Tech arena, which may present challenges if I find my interests change after starting.
• Lodging and meals not included
• Will need to take a $700 statistics course to meet prerequisites prior to matriculation
• More geographically challenging to travel to from D.C. than Wharton