Here's another one that I knew and out-thought myself on.

Question

Here's another one that I knew and out-thought myself on. The wording is ambiguous to me about what happens on that first day. Like on day 1, it's still 1, then you go from there. Am I crazy, or is this standard wording?

Professor · Answer

ttotal toady = x
1st day loss = x/2
remaining = x/2

2nd day loss = 1/2 of x/4 = x/4
remaining = x/2 - x/4 = x/4

similarly;

3rd day loss = x/8
4th day loss = x/16
5th day loss = x/32
5th day remaining = x/32

total loss = x - x/32 = 31x/32. i.e E.

microjohn · Answer

I knew that it was either 15/16 or 31/32, my question is how do you break through the wording of the question? 

Although this isn't probability, there have been several times where the first integer is 1, and then you go from there. That's my problem. At the end of day 1, I don't know if the tree has lost half of it's leaves, or if it waits until day 2 to shed them.

ps_dahiya · Answer

If you remember "Half Life" concept of radioactive materials then this should not bother you.

After Day1 - Fraction remaining = 1/2
After Day2 - Fraction remaining = 1/2 * 1/2 = 1/4
After Day3 - Fraction remaining = 1/2 * 1/2 * 1/2 = 1/8
After Day4 - Fraction remaining = 1/2 * 1/2 * 1/2 * 1/2 = 1/16
After Day5 - Fraction remaining = 1/2 * 1/2 * 1/2 * 1/2 * 1/2 = 1/32

Fraction lost = 31/32

microjohn · Answer

I get the math, I saw the trick in the answer choices...my problem was the concept of the tree itself. If each day a tree loses half it's remaining leaves, at the end of day 1 I can see the tree having all of it's leaves, and not losing half until day 2. Then at the end of day 5 it has lost 15/16. If, however, it loses half of it's "remaining" leaves on day 1, then it is 31/32.

See what I'm saying?

If the question was worded more like, "If on day 1 a tree loses half of it's leaves, and this progression continues until all of the leaves are gone, how many leaves are remaining at the end of day 5?" I would be fine...

prashrash · Answer

hi microjohn, To help you with the wordings of the question, consider this. The question speaks of a tree - and it must be a somewhat old tree for it to start shedding its leaves

. Now the questions states 'each day the tree loses half of its remaining leaves'. We are not speaking of time from the inception of the tree per se, for this problem. We are only considering the time from when this (somewhat unique) phenomenon of leaves falling started. Thus, it follows that half of the leaves would fall from the tree on the first of the days under consideration . Now count 5 days from this (including this day) and calculate the amount of leaves falling each day. You have your answer:31/32. Hope this helps. Cheers Prashrash.

jaynayak · Answer

Let the number of leaves be x

1st day it loses = x/2
2nd day it loses = x/4
3rd day it loses = x/8
4th day it loses = x/16
5th day it loses = x/32

total loss = x/2 + x/4 + x/ 8 + x/16 + x/32 = 31x/32

fraction = 31/32

Futuristic · Answer

Another way of solving this.

No of days leaves lost =5
rate of loss = 50%/day

Leaves after 5 days= Original * (0.5)^5
% loss = (orig - leaves after 5 days)/orig = orig(1-1/32)/orig = 31/32

heman · Answer

To start with the tree has x leaves
D1-lose x/2 remaining x/2
D2-lose x/4 remaing x/4
D3-lose x/8 remaining x/8
D4-lose x/16 remaining x/16
D5-lose x/32 remaining x/32

leaves lost = x -x/32
= 31x/32

Heman

Here's another one that I knew and out-thought myself on.

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards