Multi-Source Reasoning (MSR) - Non Math/Hard
Q2
For each of the following statements, select True if the statement can be reasonably inferred from Tab 3. Otherwise, select Not True.
True Not True
Some archive items have more reliable dates than others.
Some preserved works include material that was not part of the surviving original item.
The archive’s digital preservation files are treated as complete replacements for the original materials.
Q3
Which of the following statements can be most reasonably inferred from the information provided?
A. All nitrate silent films in the archive were destroyed before climate-controlled storage became available.
B. Climate-controlled storage can prevent all future deterioration of film and audio materials.
C. Some archive materials were damaged before the archive adopted its later preservation methods.
D. Magnetic audio tapes were more flammable than nitrate film.
E. The archive began creating digital preservation files before it opened any climate-controlled vaults.
Solution
Q1
Storage conditions
This is Relevant. Tab 1 connects storage conditions to curling, fading, adhesive failure, and continued deterioration. Tab 2 explains that lower temperature and humidity reduced further damage to film and audio materials. Tab 3 refers to fragile originals, restoration work, and digital files created partly to reduce handling of delicate materials. Across the tabs, preservation depends on how the items are stored, protected, or handled.
Public exhibition
This is Not Relevant. Public screenings are mentioned in Tab 3, but they are not discussed in Tab 1 or Tab 2 as a preservation factor. Since the factor is not connected to preservation outcomes in all three tabs, it is not relevant for this question.
Newspaper records
This is Not Relevant. Newspaper records are mentioned in Tab 3 as evidence that helps date some newsreels. They are not mentioned in Tab 1 or Tab 2, and they are not described as affecting physical preservation across the archive.
Correct answer:
Storage conditions: Relevant
Public exhibition: Not Relevant
Newspaper records: Not Relevant
Q2
Some archive items have more reliable dates than others.
This is True. Tab 3 says some nitrate silent films have uncertain production dates, while many newsreels have reliable dates because newspaper descriptions match the events shown. So the reliability of dating differs across archive items.
Some preserved works include material that was not part of the surviving original item.
This is True. Tab 3 says restoration notes may identify replaced frames, added title cards, or reconstructed sound sections. That means some restored works include material added during restoration.
The archive’s digital preservation files are treated as complete replacements for the original materials.
This is Not True. Tab 3 says digital preservation files are intended to reduce handling of fragile originals, not to replace the originals as historical artifacts.
Correct answer:
Some archive items have more reliable dates than others. True
Some preserved works include material that was not part of the surviving original item. True
The archive’s digital preservation files are treated as complete replacements for the original materials. Not True
Q3
A. All nitrate silent films in the archive were destroyed before climate-controlled storage became available.
This cannot be inferred. Tab 2 says fragile reels were later moved into controlled storage, so at least some materials survived long enough to be moved.
B. Climate-controlled storage can prevent all future deterioration of film and audio materials.
This cannot be inferred. Tab 2 says climate control reduced further damage, not that it prevented all future deterioration.
C. Some archive materials were damaged before the archive adopted its later preservation methods.
This can be inferred. Tab 1 describes damage during earlier basement storage, and Tab 2 says some items had already deteriorated before they were moved to controlled storage.
D. Magnetic audio tapes were more flammable than nitrate film.
This cannot be inferred. Tab 2 says magnetic audio tapes did not carry the same fire risk as nitrate film.
E. The archive began creating digital preservation files before it opened any climate-controlled vaults.
This cannot be inferred. Tab 2 says the first climate-controlled vault opened in 1968, while Tab 3 says digital preservation files began in 2005.
Correct answer:
C. Some archive materials were damaged before the archive adopted its later preservation methods.
Takeaway
The key is to track the exact role each piece of evidence plays. The tabs distinguish physical preservation, dating reliability, restoration changes, and digital copying. The correct answers depend on whether a claim is supported across the required tabs, supported only in one tab, or stronger than the evidence allows.
What This Question Tests
This question tests GMAT MSR skills such as cross-tab verification, inference control, and careful distinction between preservation, restoration, documentation, and replacement. It also tests whether the reader can reject overstatements such as “all,” “complete replacements,” and “prevent all future deterioration.”