Pritishd
Is \(p > q\)?
1. \(\sqrt{q} > p\)
2. \(q^{3} > p\)
1. I really liked this question and hence sharing it here with the larger group
2. Do give it a shot and share your approach
3. Source -
Experts' Global Option A -
Insufficient1. \(q\) will be positive because root of a negative integer is not possible
2. Say \(q = 4\) then \(\sqrt{q}\) \(= 2\) then \(p\) can be 1, 0... and \(p < q\)
3. Say \(q = \frac{1}{4}\) then \(\sqrt{q}\) \(= \frac{1}{2}\) then \(p\) can be \(\frac{1}{3}\) and \(p > q\)
Option B -
Insufficient1. Say \(q = 3\) then \(q^3\) \(= 27\) then \(p\) can be 26 and \(p > q\)
3. Say \(q = \frac{1}{2}\) then \(q^3\) \(= \frac{1}{8}\) then \(p\) can be \(\frac{1}{9}\) and \(p < q\)
Combining both statements, we get:-1. \(q\) is positive
2. If \(q\) is an positive integer then \(q^3 > q > \sqrt{q} > p\)
3. If \(q\) is a positive fraction then \(\sqrt{q} > q > q^3 > p\)
4. \(q\) will always be greater than \(p\)
Ans.
C