What is the probability that u/v/w and x/y/z are reciprocal fractions?

Please find the solution of this problem attached.

I got this one wrong. Please correct my reasoning:

1 - we only know about v,w,y,z. No information about u and x - Insufficient
2. u*x is the median of 100 consecutive integers. Firstly, the only information provided is about u and x and secondly, the the consecutive integers can start from anywhere. They may be negative positive, some negative some positive, so Insufficient

Combining the two, We have some information about v,w,y,z but info about u and x is unclear

So E

@ThoughttoSphere:

the question stem can be rephrased as : Is (v)(w)(y)(z)=(u)(x) ?

Statement 1: really doesn't tells us anything except that v,w , y and z are integers chosen from the first 100 positive integers. Clearly not sufficient.

Statement 2: tells us that product of x and u is the median of 100 consecutive integers. Now whatever be the set of 100 consecutive integers, the median is always going to be the mean of the 50th and 51st term and since the terms are consecutive, the median will be x.5 which is not an integer. Clearly not sufficient by itself.

Combining 1 and 2 - we can surely tell that since v,w,y and z are integers their product can never be equal to a fraction.

Hence C.

Please explain how did you get

the question stem can be rephrased as : Is (v)(w)(y)(z)=(u)(x) ?

u/v/w & x/y/z are the two fractions given.


I can interpret it in two ways

1. [u/v] / w & [x/y] / z ....in this case ...we get the equation ux = yzvw ...and hence ans C.

2. But if i interpret the fraction as

U / [v/w] & X / [y/z] ....in this case....we get the equation uwxz = vy ...i.e. ux = vy / wz i.e. 50.5 = vy / wz [50.5 if we consider 1 to 100]

So this equation can give somenumber point five and no way we can determine if reciprocals or not . Hence here ans E.


@@bunuel ....should the question have more clarity . Please suggest.

Not sure about the answer as the expression in the question is not clear. I could not get an expression which I could take as a premise. Different interpretations, different expressions. Bunuel.. a little help please!

Question: (u*w)/v = y/(x*z) ?
[1] v, w, y, z E {1,2, ... 99, 100} Not sufficient...
[2] ux = (50+51)/2 = 101/2 = 50.5 Not sufficient...
[1]+[2]: ux = 50.5 = (v/w)*(y/z)
Now no pair of random values from 1 to 100 can form (101/2) as 101 is a prime number. So ux |= (v/w)*(y/z) => (u*w)/v |= y/(x*z) Sufficient.
Answer C

This can be simplified as follows:
What is the probability that ux/vy/wz = 1 ?
What is the probability that ux/vy = wz ?
Finally: What is the probability that ux = vywz ?

Statement (1) tells us that vywz is an integer, since it is the product of integers. However, this gives no information about u and x and is herefore not sufficient to answer the question.

Statement (2) tells us that ux is NOT an integer. This is because the median of an even number of consecutive integers is NOT an integer. (For example, the median of 4 consecut ive integers - 9, 10, 11, 12 - equals 10.5.) However, this gives us no information about vywz and is therefore not sufficient to answer the question. Taking both statements together, we know that vywz IS an integer and that ux is NOT an integer. Therefore vywz CANNOT be equal to ux. The probability that the fractions are
reciprocals is zero. The correct answer is C: Statements (1) and (2) TAKEN TOGETHER are sufficient to answer the question, but NEITHER statement ALONE is sufficient

if we know we can calculate the probability that all x,z,u,w,v, and y are integers, we get the answer.

Hi anairamitch1804 Bunuel chetan2u

can we call 1/2.5 as a fraction or fraction needs to be strictly reduced form of integers?

Thanks

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________