Sajjad1994 wrote:
kntombat wrote:
Sajjad1994, could you please post the official explanation for this question as and when possible, it would be a big help in understanding where did I go wrong the first time when I attempted the question.
Thank you.
Official Explanation
Any information that helps determine the actual cause of the immediate performance boost will help evaluate the researcher’s hypothesis. Of the five avenues of investigation listed, only choice (E) will yield this type of information. If it turns out that a new chain reduces gear friction, thereby allowing the cyclist to ride just as fast but with less effort, then this fact would help disprove the researcher’s hypothesis—especially if friction increases materially during the first three weeks of use.
The correct answer is (E).
I believe it's really important to understand to what degree the given answer choices help us to evaluate the argument, in this case, the hypothesis that "that installing a new component, such as a chain, gives a competitive cyclist a psychological boost, which helps motivate that cyclist during a race".
The answer choices A, B, C are not even in consideration.
For me it was straight D (if a competitive cyclist can tell merely by riding a bicycle whether it has a new chain or an older chain). However, even answer choice E also helps us to evaluate the hypothesis and therefore, both D and E are helping us to evaluate.
What choice is more helpful is a BIG question and in my experience, I haven't experienced such questions as official.
Will be keen to know
Sajjad1994 opinion on why D can't be the answer or why E is better than D?