Question 3
INSEADIESE wrote:
GMATNinja wrote:
bapism07 wrote:
Hi all
I have a query on the question -3. i.e. (It can be inferred from the passage that the “scholars” mentioned in line 24 believe which of the following to be true?)
As per the third paragraph, it is mentioned that Garvey created the consciousness and that called for the largest revitalization movement. in the next line, the author mentions that the whole thing can tend to obscure as it was already there. Therefore he did not create or build the consciousness for the revitalization movement.
For the above references, we can conclude that the ideology was always prevailing and Garvey gave it a new political expression to it. Hence why not option C?
Hope i am not wrong!
thanks
subhankar
Quote:
3. It can be inferred from the passage that the “scholars” mentioned in the highlight text believe which of the following to be true?
A. Revitalization resulted from the political activism of returning African American soldiers following the First World War.
B. Marcus Garvey had to change a number of prevailing attitudes in order for his mass movement to find a foothold in the United States.
C. The prevailing sensibility of the African American community provided the foundation of Marcus Garvey’s political appeal.
D. Marcus Garvey hoped to revitalize consciousness of cultural and historical identity in the African American community.
E. The goal of the mass movement that Marcus Garvey helped bring into being was to build on the pride and unity among African Americans.
Question #3 asks us to select something that the SCHOLARS believe to be true, not something that the AUTHOR OF THE PASSAGE believes to be true. Those scholars believe "that Garvey created the consciousness from which he built." Thus, those scholars would believe that Garvey had to change a number of prevailing attitudes (B).
Even if this question were asking about the author's beliefs, choice (C) is still questionable. Where does the author talk about the
sensibility of the African American community? The author mentions "the consciousness of identity, strength, and sense of history that already existed in the African American community" but not sensibility. This is the type of mistake described in the "Don’t fall in love" section of the
Ultimate RC Guide for Beginners.
Regardless, choice (C) does not match the
scholar's beliefs.
I hope that helps!
Hi Gmatninja
as per the context of the passage, what is the difference between "sensibility" and "consciousness" ?
dictionary definition of "sensibility" : the quality of being able to appreciate and respond to complex emotional or aesthetic influences; sensitivity.
dictionary definition of "consciousness" : the state of being aware of and responsive to one's surroundings.
now, both the definitions seem fine as per the given context of the passage, so your reasoning regarding the difference between the two words seems a little weird.
please explain as soon as you can.
Regards,
As we said in our previous post, the best reason to eliminate (C) is that the question asks about the SCHOLARS’ beliefs, not the AUTHOR’S beliefs. For that reason, (C) is undoubtedly wrong.
However, we also noted that the use of the word “sensibility” is
questionable because while the words “consciousness” and “sensibility” possess similar meanings, they do not mean the same thing in the context of the passage.
When the author indicates that the African American community was
conscious of its “identity, strength, and sense of history,” he/she simply means that the community was aware of these factors. However, to say that the African American community possessed a
sensibility implies not only an awareness, but also a response to emotional or aesthetic stimuli, which is not the author’s apparent intention.
In short, the distinction between “sensibility” and “consciousness” is definitely not the best reason to eliminate (C), but the use of the former in place of the latter is certainly
questionable.
I hope that helps!