IMO CTo determine which assumption the argument relies on, let's break down the argument and identify the underlying assumptions.
Argument Breakdown:
Problem: The company faces high absentee rates.
Solution: The company introduced mandatory morning health check-ins.
Potential Issue: Research indicates that mandatory check-ins can lead to feelings of surveillance among employees.
Consequence: Feelings of surveillance can potentially decrease job satisfaction.
Conclusion: Therefore, the health check-ins might not reduce absenteeism as intended.
Key Assumption:
For the argument to hold, it must be assumed that job satisfaction significantly influences absenteeism. If job satisfaction does not affect absenteeism, then the potential decrease in job satisfaction due to feelings of surveillance would not impact absenteeism rates.
Analysis of Each Option:
Option A: The health check-ins have been fully implemented and are conducted regularly each morning.
This option assumes that the check-ins are implemented as planned, but it does not address the relationship between job satisfaction and absenteeism, which is crucial for the argument.
Option B: Employees’ feelings of being monitored are not worse than any other feelings of dissatisfaction they may have due to other company policies.
This option compares feelings of being monitored to other dissatisfaction sources but does not address the impact of job satisfaction on absenteeism.
Option C: The level of job satisfaction among employees is a significant factor influencing their rates of absenteeism.
This option directly addresses the assumption that job satisfaction influences absenteeism rates. If job satisfaction is not a significant factor, then the argument that decreased job satisfaction due to health check-ins would not impact absenteeism falls apart.
Option D: Before the health check-ins were implemented, no employees reported their health status voluntarily.
This option discusses the previous behavior of employees but does not address the relationship between job satisfaction and absenteeism.
Option E: Employees typically do not react negatively to other forms of monitoring or reporting that the company has implemented.
This option discusses employees' reactions to other forms of monitoring but does not address the crucial link between job satisfaction and absenteeism.
Conclusion:
Option C is the correct assumption.Explanation: The argument relies on the assumption that job satisfaction is a significant factor influencing absenteeism rates. If job satisfaction does not affect absenteeism, then the potential decrease in job satisfaction due to feelings of surveillance from mandatory health check-ins would not impact absenteeism rates. Therefore, the argument that health check-ins might not reduce absenteeism as intended hinges on this assumption.