Answer C
Analyzing the Argument:
The argument concludes that the mandatory health check-ins might not reduce absenteeism as intended, because they could decrease job satisfaction by making employees feel monitored. For this argument to hold, it must assume that job satisfaction significantly influences absenteeism—otherwise, a decline in job satisfaction wouldn’t matter for absenteeism rates.
Evaluating the Answer Choices:
• (A) The health check-ins have been fully implemented and are conducted regularly each morning.
• This is not an assumption; it’s more of a factual detail about the implementation of the policy. The argument does not depend on whether the policy is fully implemented; it depends on the relationship between job satisfaction and absenteeism.
• Eliminate A.
• (B) Employees’ feelings of being monitored are not worse than any other feelings of dissatisfaction they may have due to other company policies.
• The argument doesn’t compare this policy to other policies. The focus is on whether feelings of surveillance affect job satisfaction and, in turn, absenteeism.
• Eliminate B.
• (C) The level of job satisfaction among employees is a significant factor influencing their rates of absenteeism.
• This directly connects the premise (decline in job satisfaction due to health check-ins) to the conclusion (the check-ins might not reduce absenteeism). If job satisfaction doesn’t significantly influence absenteeism, then the argument falls apart.
• This is the assumption.
• (D) Before the health check-ins were implemented, no employees reported their health status voluntarily.
• This is irrelevant. The argument concerns the effects of mandatory check-ins on absenteeism, not whether health reporting occurred previously.
• Eliminate D.
• (E) Employees typically do not react negatively to other forms of monitoring or reporting that the company has implemented.
• While this might seem relevant, the argument doesn’t hinge on how employees react to other forms of monitoring. It focuses on the specific reaction to this policy and its impact on absenteeism.
• Eliminate E.
Conclusion:
The argument assumes that job satisfaction is an important factor influencing absenteeism. C is the correct answer.
Bunuel
12 Days of Christmas 2024 - 2025 Competition with $40,000 of PrizesTo decrease the rate of absenteeism, a company introduced mandatory morning health check-ins where employees must report their well-being status before starting work. The company often faces high absentee rates, which prompted the introduction of this policy. However, research indicates that such mandatory check-ins can lead to feelings of surveillance among employees, potentially decreasing job satisfaction. Therefore, the health check-ins might not reduce absenteeism as intended.
The argument relies on which of the following as an assumption?
(A) The health check-ins have been fully implemented and are conducted regularly each morning.
(B) Employees’ feelings of being monitored are not worse than any other feelings of dissatisfaction they may have due to other company policies.
(C) The level of job satisfaction among employees is a significant factor influencing their rates of absenteeism.
(D) Before the health check-ins were implemented, no employees reported their health status voluntarily.
(E) Employees typically do not react negatively to other forms of monitoring or reporting that the company has implemented.