A. Dreaming is not only about the duration of REM sleep.
Eliminated This does not effect the conclusion in any way, as the conclusion is about duration of REM sleep.
B. The argument fails to specify the exact duration of REM sleep in the 1950s and nowadays.
Eliminated As the exact duration does not invalidate the fact that the duration has decreased when compared to previous data.
C.
Modern day participants may have been chosen so that their results reflect the decrease suggested by the research.
Suitable as only 100 participants have been selected for study, there are chances of heavy selection bias in such studies and sample may have been molded to suit the desired conclusion.
D. The research does not refer to international statistics to show whether or not the decline has occurred globally.
Eliminated The conclusion is concerned only with "American Dreamers"
E. The title of the research does not properly reflect the results of the research.
Eliminated Out of context for the answer