Hi bschoolcurious,
Happy to help. I will do my best to be balanced. However, this will not be easy. Here's why -
- Only 4 firms interviewed - I only spoke to 4 admissions consulting firms before making my choice. The 4 that made my shortlist were based on reviews on gmatclub and beatthegmat. So, I obviously can't speak for all.
- 2 I really liked. I almost ended up working with MBAprepschool (after speaking with Chris Aitken) and have only positive things to say about my conversation and interactions with him. I ended up choosing
Stratus prep because I liked Shawn's process and the idea of having multiple people review my application versus the traditional 1 coach model.
- Successful application. The final and most important reason for the bias would be that the application was successful. It's hard to not look at it with rose tinted glasses but I'll try.
Strengths
1. Solid process with multiple reviewers. THis is why I chose
Stratus prep and they lived up to their promise. I think most top firms have great coaches (I saw most because a friend of mine had a bad experience after spending $8000). I liked the idea of having multiple reviewers and I had 3-4 people look at my application and I think this made the process better.
2. Unlimited access to the coach. Some firms constrain this. I had none of that. It's not that I spoke to the coach more than once a week but the knowledge that access was unlimited helped
3. More or less full time staff. I think this helps. You don't want your coach to be checking your essays at the end of a hard day's work as a consultant/banker. I think all of Shawn's employees are full time - the folks I dealt with certainly were.
Weaknesses
1. You aren't pushed enough to meet deadlines. This can be a problem and is one I've pointed out in my review. I don't know how other firms do it but I think this would be useful. THe flip side is that you are treated like an adult and expected to own your process.
I can't think of any other obvious weaknesses (probably my rose tinted glasses). I enjoyed working with
Stratus prep and I've written a detailed review (it is the longest of Status prep reviews and ends with a PS asking you to reach out to Shawn if you'd like to speak to me directly).
Let me know if this helps/if you have any other specific questions. I've sent you a pm as well from another gmatclub account. I find this question really hard - it is similar to asking a Booth grad about the strengths and weaknesses of MIT or Stanford. Hard to know when you haven't done it yourself but the Booth grad would probably be able to help you with a review on Booth - I've hopefully done that.
Finally, I did remember seeing a fair number of posts abuot
Stratus prep reviews being from new members. Communities typically work on 1/10/90 rule where 1% are the really active users, 10% are the occasional posters and 90% are the lurkers. I think relying on the 1% would lead to a bit of a recency bias of sorts (I keep hearing from you so I assume you are right) - I think many of the others have equally legit views and just aren't all that active.
All that said, wish you all the best with your applications!