generis wrote:
Project SC Butler: Day 34 Sentence Correction (SC1)
By studying the primitive visual systems of single-cell aquatic organisms,
biophysicists have discovered a striking similarity between algae and cows, a similarity that indicates the common evolutionary origin of plants and animals: both algae and cows produce a light-sensitive protein called rhodopsin.
(A) biophysicists have discovered a striking similarity between algae and cows
(B) a striking similarity between algae and cows has been discovered by biophysicists
(C) there is a striking similarity that biophysicists have discovered between algae and cows
(D) the discovery of a striking similarity between algae and cows was made by biophysicists
(E) algae and cows have a striking similarity that was discovered by biophysicists
OFFICIAL EXPLANATIONMy annotations are in blue typeface.• This question requires that the opening participial phrase modify the subject of the sentence,
biophysicists."opening participial phrase" = First verbING phrase =
[By studying the primitive visual systems of single-cell aquatic organisms]• The subject should therefore be placed as close to the phrase as possible.
• Choice A places the subject next to the phrase and is the best choice
• In choice B
a similarity is doing the studying
• In choice D
the discovery is doing the studying, and
• In choice E
the algae and the cows are doing the studying.
• By placing
there is next to the phrase, choice C leaves the participle with nothing to modify
COMMENTSparijit and
lary301254M7 , glad to have you on the thread.
(If I have welcomed you before, forgive my forgetfulness. It's hard to recall who posts on which thread.)
Comments on Answer CAnswer C is nonsensical. No logical connection exists between "By studying" and the
entire "there is" clause.
If the opening modifier has nothing to modify, Option C offers zero logic rather than
the ludicrous logic offered by options B, D, and E.
-------------
We have two excellent answers whose authors avoided trying to rewrite
this sentence "in plain English" in the full sense.
That is,
Prateekj05 and
lary301254M7 "rewrote" the meaning, but in a way
that both made the sentence comprehensible and did not grapple unnecessarily
with insanely boring and distracting details.
Analysis of (C) was a little off, but that's okay; by comparison to (A), option C stands no chance.
Excellent work. Kudos to both.
_________________
—The only thing more dangerous than ignorance is arrogance. ~Einstein—I stand with Ukraine.
Donate to Help Ukraine!