HYSTERICAL PRE-DECISION READING.
NPR STORY ABOUT BEING INSIDE AMHERST COLLEGE ADCOM AS IT MAKES DECISIONS. SCARY, IF TRUE, WHICH I DOUBT. ALTHO THIS PART MIGHT BE TRUE-R THAN THEN IMAGINE.
Quote:
We're trying to separate the James Browns from the James Taylors, he says, and it's a daunting task.
RIGHT, AND AS YOU KNOW, JAMES TAYLOR WILL NEVER MAKE IT INTO AMHERST.
https://www.npr.org/2011/03/28/134916924/Amherst-Admissions-ProcessSMITH: This one will fly, but another student's essay, read by Dean Kathleen Mayberry, will prove fatal.
Ms. KATHLEEN MAYBERRY (Dean, Amherst College): I'm troubled by one sentence in the first essay: I rarely get truly fascinated with a subject. And then he goes on - music is his exception. What am I supposed to do with that?
Mr. PARKER: My jaw dropped. I mean, that was flabbergasting.
SMITH: Intellectual passion is a must, says Parker. The students who get in are the ones who come across as genuine. It also helps to come across as different.
Unidentified Man #2: Vice president of the Jewish Club, president of the Japanese Society, an active member of the Muslim Club, and lastly, an observant of Hindu traditions.
Mr. PARKER: There is going to come a point where it's going to be very close to, you know, closing your eyes and doing that, because we're exhausting the meaningful criteria to separate John from Mary. For that group, it's effectively a lottery. It really is.