Bunuel
Company X and Company Y are in the business of manufacturing memory cards. Company X sells twice as many memory cards as does Company Y and Company X also has fewer employees than Company Y does. So Company X must be making more profits than Company Y.
Which of the following options best helps to evaluate the argument?
(A) Whether there are any other companies that manufacture memory cards in addition to Company X and Company Y.
(B) Whether both the companies pay similar average salaries to their employees.
(C) Whether Company X will be able to sustain its high sales in the future.
(D) Whether the memory cards of the two companies have similar storage capacities.
(E) Whether Company X is likely to hire more employees in the near future.
There are two companies X and Y and both sell memory cards. The quantity of memory cards sold by companies X and Y are 2a and a respectively.
Let the number of employees in companies X and Y are b and 3b respectively.
So, it’s finally concluded that Company X makes more profit than company Y.
(A) Whether there are any other companies that manufacture memory cards in addition to Company X and Company Y.
Option A is wrong because - even if there is another company which manufactures, their sales volume or market share is the factor which is gonna affect the profits of both companies. This cannot be used as a factor to make a comparison of profits between company X and company Y.
(B) Whether both the companies pay similar average salaries to their employees.Given the facts, if the companies pay similar average salaries. Then the profit of company X is higher compared to Company Y, provided the sales price is same for both the companies.
(C) Whether Company X will be able to sustain its high sales in the future.
Option C is wrong, as high sales may or may not affect the profit.
(D) Whether the memory cards of the two companies have similar storage capacities.
Storage capacities is not relevant to the question. Hence, wrong.
(E) Whether Company X is likely to hire more employees in the near future.
Option E is wrong - if company X can hire more employees, their expenses can increase. The profits may or may not increase.
Option B