kalaivana
Mark yeah I meant D. Thanks for explaining.
Leaving aside this question,are the statements not supposed to be contradicting each other in any DS problem? That's news to me.
That's right. All DS problems from GMAC are carefully written so that the statements don't contradict each other. They do this so that you're able to try the statements together (even if the answer is A, B, or D) without creating a contradiction.
This has a couple of important consequences. First, if you ever think that two statements are sufficient by themselves (answer choice D) for different reasons (e.g., a Yes/No question where Statement 1 gives you YES only while Statement 2 gives you NO only), you know you made a mistake and should recheck the statements.
Second, if you're sure that Statement 1 is sufficient, the answer you get for Statement 1 must be a
possible answer for Statement 2. For example, if you're sure that Statement 1 is YES only, you can assume that YES is a possible answer for Statement 2. Then, you just need to check if NO is also possible for Statement 2. If a NO is also possible, the answer is A; otherwise, the answer is D.
Occasionally you'll see unofficial questions, like the one you posted, where the statements do contradict each other, but GMAC has always been very consistent about avoiding such contradictions with official questions in the OG and online question sets.
Let me know if that answers your question.