conclusion= city officials should be applauded for their role in preventing crisis.
reason= city officials initiated program that encouraged residents to reduce their waste usage by 20%.
since the program was announced, the water level at all three reservoirs has returned to normal.
so typical causation and correlation que. we need to find the reason that its something else that helped and not the action from officials.
A passage already says that level has returned to normal level. so it doesnt matter its still lower than last year. its also focusing on comparing water level and not on why this happened. so reject.
B this is interesting. this means the effects can be seen across the reservoirs. so its not officials plan but something else helped to get back to normal level. may be some extra rain. so this does enough to attack the conclusion. keep.
C this is comparing the activities done by residents and which did they do more of. this is going in other direction though. reject.
D that means officials plan worked and had they been more strict with penalties, result would have been far better. this somewhat strengthen it. out.
E this also strengthen somehow. reject.
option B
Bunuel
Earlier this year, our city’s three main reservoirs had unusually low water levels. As a result, city officials initiated a program that encouraged residents to reduce their water usage by 20 percent. Since the program was announced, the water level at all three reservoirs has returned to normal. Our city officials should be applauded for their role in preventing a crisis.
Which of the following, if true, casts the most doubt on the efficacy of the officials’ program?
(A) The current water level in the reservoirs is lower than it was at the same time last year.
(B) Other nearby reservoirs recovered from lower water levels this year, even though those reservoirs provide water to cities that did not enact water restriction policies.
(C) Residents reduced their water usage for lawn maintenance significantly more than they did for washing clothes.
(D) Imposing stiff penalties on residents who did not conserve water would have resulted in even higher water levels in the reservoirs.
(E) Water usage in the city dropped steadily during the first two weeks of the program before leveling off.