Eight times within the past million years, something in the Earth’s cl

Question

Project RC Butler 2020  -  Participate and win GMAT Club Tests.   
Passage # 165 Date: 22-Jun-2020
 This post is a part of Project RC Butler 2020 .  Click here for Details

1999-04 SECTION A 17-24

Eight times within the past million years, something in the Earth’s climatic equation has changed, allowing snow in the mountains and the northern latitudes to accumulate from one season to the next instead of melting away. Each time, the enormous ice sheets resulting from this continual buildup lasted tens of thousands of years until the end of each particular glacial cycle brought a warmer climate. Scientists speculated that these glacial cycles were ultimately driven by astronomical factors: slow, cyclic changes in the eccentricity of the Earth’s orbit and in the tilt and orientation of its spin axis. But up until around 30 years ago, the lack of an independent record of ice-age timing made the hypothesis untestable.

Then in the early 1950’s Emiliani produced the first complete record of the waxings and wanings of past glaciations. It came from a seemingly odd place, the seafloor. Single-cell marine organisms called “foraminifera” house themselves in shells made from calcium carbonate. When the foraminifera die, sink to the bottom, and become part of seafloor sediments, the carbonate of their shells preserves certain characteristics of the seawater they inhabited. In particular, the ratio of a heavy isotope of oxygen (oxygen-18) to ordinary oxygen (oxygen-16) in the carbonate preserves the ratio of the two oxygens in water molecules. It is now understood that the ratio of oxygen isotopes in seawater closely reflects the proportion of the world’s water locked up in glaciers and ice sheets. A kind of meteorological distillation accounts for the link. Water molecules containing the heavier isotope tend to condense and fall as precipitation slightly sooner than molecules containing the lighter isotope. Hence, as water vapor evaporated from warm oceans moves away from its source, its oxygen-18 returns more quickly to the oceans than does its oxygen-16. What falls as snow on distant ice sheets and mountain glaciers is relatively depleted of oxygen-18. As the oxygen-18-poor ice builds up, the oceans become relatively enriched in the isotope. The larger the ice sheets grow, the higher the proportion of oxygen-18 becomes in seawater—and hence in the sediments.

Analyzing cores drilled from seafloor sediments, Emiliani found that the isotopic ratio rose and fell in rough accord with the Earth’s astronomical cycles. Since that pioneering observation, oxygen-isotope measurements have been made on hundreds of cores. A chronology for the combined record enables scientists to show that the record contains the very same periodicities as the orbital processes. Over the past 800,000 years, the global ice volume has peaked every 100,000 years, matching the period of the orbital eccentricity variation. In addition, “wrinkles” superposed on each cycle—small decreases or surges in ice volume—have come at intervals of roughly 23,000 and 41,000 years, in keeping with the precession and tilt frequencies of the Earth’s spin axis.  
 1 
 1.​​Which of the following best expresses the main idea of the passage?

(A) Marine sediments have allowed scientists to amass evidence tending to confirm that astronomical cycles drive the Earth’s glacial cycles.
(B) The ratio between two different isotopes of oxygen in seawater correlates closely with the size of the Earth’s ice sheets.
(C) Surprisingly, single-cell marine organisms provide a record of the Earth’s ice ages.
(D) The Earth’s astronomical cycles have recently been revealed to have an unexpectedly large impact on the Earth’s climate.
(E) The earth has experienced eight periods of intense glaciation in the past million years, primarily as a result of substantial changes in its orbit.

2 
 ​2. ​​The passage asserts that one reason that oceans become enriched in oxygen-18 as ice sheets grow is because

(A) water molecules containing oxygen-18 condense and fall as precipitation slightly sooner than those containing oxygen-16
(B) the ratio of oxygen-18 to oxygen-16 in water vapor evaporated from oceans is different from that of these isotopes in seawater
(C) growing ice sheets tend to lose their oxygen-18 as the temperature of the oceans near them gradually decreases
(D) less water vapor evaporates from oceans during glacial periods and therefore less oxygen-18 is removed from the seawater
(E) the freezing point of seawater rich in oxygen-18 is slightly lower than that of seawater poor in oxygen-18

3 
 3. ​​​​According to the passage, the large ice sheets typical of glacial cycles are most directly caused by

(A) changes in the average temperatures in the tropics and over open oceans
(B) prolonged increases in the rate at which water evaporates from the oceans
(C) extreme seasonal variations in temperature in northern latitudes and in mountainous areas
(D) steadily increasing precipitation rates in northern latitudes and in mountainous areas
(E) the continual failure of snow to melt completely during the warmer seasons in northern latitudes and in mountainous areas

4 
 4. ​​​​​​​​​​It can be inferred from the passage that which of the following is true of the water locked in glaciers and ice sheets today?

(A) It is richer in oxygen-18 than frozen water was during past glacial periods.
(B) It is primarily located in the northern latitudes of the Earth.
(C) Its ratio of oxygen isotopes is the same as that prevalent in seawater during the last ice age.
(D) It is steadily decreasing in amount due to increased thawing during summer months.
(E) In comparison with seawater, it is relatively poor in oxygen-18.

5 
 5. ​​​​​​​The discussion of the oxygen-isotope ratios in paragraph three of the passage suggests that which of the following must be assumed if the conclusions described in lines 49-58 are to be validly drawn?

(A) The Earth’s overall annual precipitation rates do not dramatically increase or decrease over time.
(B) The various chemicals dissolved in seawater have had the same concentrations over the past million years.
concentrations over the past million years.
(C) Natural processes unrelated to ice formation do not result in the formation of large quantities of oxygen-18.
(D) Water molecules falling as precipitation usually fall on the open ocean rather than on continents or polar ice packs.
(E) Increases in global temperature do not increase the amount of water that evaporates from the oceans.

6 
 6. ​​​​​​​​​​The passage suggests that the scientists who first constructed a coherent, continuous picture of past variations in marine-sediment isotope ratios did which of the following?

(A) Relied primarily on the data obtained from the analysis of Emiliani’s core samples.
(B) Combined data derived from the analysis of many different core samples.
(C) Matched the data obtained by geologists with that provided by astronomers.
(D) Evaluated the isotope-ratio data obtained in several areas in order to eliminate all but the most reliable data.
(E) Compared data obtained from core samples in many different marine environments with data samples derived from polar ice caps.

7 
 7. ​​​​​​​​The passage suggests that the scientists mentioned in line 8 considered their reconstruction of past astronomical cycles to be

(A) unreliable because astronomical observations have been made and recorded for only a few thousand years
(B) adequate enough to allow that reconstruction’s use in explaining glacial cycles if a record of the latter could be found
(C) in need of confirmation through comparison with an independent source of information about astronomical phenomena
(D) incomplete and therefore unusable for the purposes of explaining the causes of ice ages
(E) adequate enough for scientists to support conclusively the idea that ice ages were caused by astronomical changes

auradediligodo · Accepted Answer

Hi everyone,
Got 4/6 correct in 14 minutes, including 5:30 minutes to read and 8:30 minutes to answer. I skipped question 5 as there are no lines and the lines of the passage here do not correspond with the lines of the original passage. Very poor posting.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

P1

In this paragraph the author presents the main topic: Ice ages. We are given that such ages are cyclic and that scientists tried to link the cyclicity with astronomical events. Unfortunately they did not have sufficient evidence.

Purpose:   To present a claim of some scientists according to whom ice ages can be linked with astronomical events.

P2

Paragraph 2 is very technical. Here the author explains how a scientist named Emiliani found a way to create that record that the other scientists didn't have. He finds a link between some evidence present in the seawater and the amount of ice produced during glaciation. Long story short, the carbonate present in some shells on the bottom of the sea contains some isotopes, whose ratio is indicative of how much ice was there during a glaciation. The more the ice, the higher the concentration of isotope 18 in the shell in the seafloor.

Purpose:  To explain how Emiliani linked the amount of ice during glaciation with the concentration of isotope 18 in seafloor's shells.

P3

In the last paragraph the author says that the correlation between periodicities of ice ages and those of astronomical events can be linked.

Purpose:  To confirm periodicities of ice ages and those of astronomical events.

Main point

The main point of this passage is show how periodicities of ice ages were proved to be linked with those of astronomical events, analyzing the work of Emiliani.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1.​​Which of the following best expresses the main idea of the passage?

Pre-thinking

Main point question

The main point of this passage is show how periodicities of ice ages were proved to be linked with those of astronomical events, analyzing the work of Emiliani.

(A)   Marine sediments have allowed scientists to amass evidence tending to confirm that astronomical cycles drive the Earth’s glacial cycles.
(B) The ratio between two different isotopes of oxygen in seawater correlates closely with the size of the Earth’s ice sheets.  Partial scope 
(C)   Surprisingly  , single-cell marine organisms provide a record of the Earth’s ice ages.  inconsistent 
(D) The Earth’s astronomical cycles have   recently   been revealed to have an   unexpectedly   large impact on the Earth’s climate.  inconsistent 
(E) The earth has experienced eight periods of intense glaciation in the past million years,   primarily as a result of substantial changes in its orbit.   inconsistent

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2. ​​The passage asserts that one reason that oceans become enriched in oxygen-18 as ice sheets grow is because

Pre-thinking

Detail question

Water molecules containing the heavier isotope tend to condense and fall as precipitation slightly sooner than molecules containing the lighter isotope.

(A)   water molecules containing oxygen-18 condense and fall as precipitation slightly sooner than those containing oxygen-16
(B) the ratio of oxygen-18 to oxygen-16 in water vapor evaporated from oceans is different from that of these isotopes in seawater  such comparison is never mentioned 
(C) growing ice sheets tend to lose their oxygen-18 as the temperature of the oceans near them gradually decreases  never mentioned 
(D) less water vapor evaporates from oceans during glacial periods and therefore less oxygen-18 is removed from the seawater  opposite 
(E) the freezing point of seawater rich in oxygen-18 is slightly lower than that of seawater poor in oxygen-18  never mentioned

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

3. ​​​​According to the passage, the large ice sheets typical of glacial cycles are most directly caused by

Pre-thinking

detail question

From P1:   Eight times within the past million years, something in the Earth’s climatic equation has changed, allowing snow in the mountains and the northern latitudes to accumulate from one season to the next instead of melting away.

(A) changes in the average temperatures in the tropics and over open oceans
(B) prolonged increases in the rate at which water evaporates from the oceans
(C) extreme seasonal variations in temperature in northern latitudes and in mountainous areas
(D) steadily   increasing precipitation rates   in northern latitudes and in mountainous areas 
  (E)   the continual failure of snow to melt completely during the warmer seasons in northern latitudes and in mountainous areas

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

4. ​​​​​​​​​​It can be inferred from the passage that which of the following is true of the water locked in glaciers and ice sheets today?

Pre-thinking

Inference question

From P2:   The larger the ice sheets grow, the higher the proportion of oxygen-18 becomes in seawater—and hence in the sediments.

(A) It is richer in oxygen-18 than frozen water was during past glacial periods.  opposite 
(B)  It is primarily located in the northern latitudes of the Earth. 
(C) Its ratio of oxygen isotopes is the  same  as that prevalent in seawater during the last ice age.
(D)  It is steadily decreasing in amount due to increased thawing during summer months. 
  (E)   In comparison with seawater, it is relatively poor in oxygen-18.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

5. ​​​​​​​The discussion of the oxygen-isotope ratios in paragraph three of the passage suggests that which of the following must be assumed if the conclusions described in lines 49-58 are to be validly drawn?

Pre-thinking

Assumption question

I guess that the conclusions mentioned are related to this part of P2:

It is now understood that the ratio of oxygen isotopes in seawater closely reflects the proportion of the world’s water locked up in glaciers and ice sheets. A kind of meteorological distillation accounts for the link. Water molecules containing the heavier isotope tend to condense and fall as precipitation slightly sooner than molecules containing the lighter isotope. Hence, as water vapor evaporated from warm oceans moves away from its source, its oxygen-18 returns more quickly to the oceans than does its oxygen-16. What falls as snow on distant ice sheets and mountain glaciers is relatively depleted of oxygen-18. As the oxygen-18-poor ice builds up, the oceans become relatively enriched in the isotope. The larger the ice sheets grow, the higher the proportion of oxygen-18 becomes in seawater—and hence in the sediments.

(A) The Earth’s overall annual precipitation rates do not dramatically increase or decrease over time.  not a must be true statement 
(B) The various chemicals dissolved in seawater have had the same concentrations over the past million years. 
concentrations over the past million years.  not a must be true statement 
  (C)   Natural processes unrelated to ice formation do not result in the formation of large quantities of oxygen-18.  Correct, if natural processes would have such effect, all the evidence gathered would be meaningless 
(D) Water molecules falling as precipitation usually fall on the open ocean rather than on continents or polar ice packs.  not a must be true statement 
(E) Increases in global temperature do not increase the amount of water that evaporates from the oceans.  not a must be true statement

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

6. ​​​​​​​​​​The passage suggests that the scientists who first constructed a coherent, continuous picture of past variations in marine-sediment isotope ratios did which of the following?

Pre-thinking

Inference question

From P3:   Analyzing cores drilled from seafloor sediments, Emiliani found that the isotopic ratio rose and fell in rough accord with the Earth’s astronomical cycles. Since that pioneering observation, oxygen-isotope measurements have been made on hundreds of cores. A chronology for the combined record enables scientists to show that the record contains the very same periodicities as the orbital processes.

(A) Relied primarily on the data obtained from the analysis of Emiliani’s core samples.  Cannot be inferred 
  (B)   Combined data derived from the analysis of many different core samples.
(C) Matched the data obtained by geologists with that provided by astronomers.  Cannot be inferred 
(D) Evaluated the isotope-ratio data obtained in several areas in order to eliminate all but the most reliable data.  Cannot be inferred 
(E) Compared data obtained from core samples in many different marine environments with data samples derived from polar ice caps.  Cannot be inferred

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

7. ​​​​​​​​The passage suggests that the scientists mentioned in line 8 considered their reconstruction of past astronomical cycles to be

Pre-thinking

Inference question

From P1:   Scientists speculated that these glacial cycles were ultimately driven by astronomical factors: slow, cyclic changes in the eccentricity of the Earth’s orbit and in the tilt and orientation of its spin axis.  But up until around 30 years ago, the lack of an independent record of ice-age timing made the hypothesis untestable.

(A) unreliable because astronomical observations have been made and recorded for only a few thousand years  out of scope 
  (B)   adequate enough to allow that reconstruction’s use in explaining glacial cycles if a record of the latter could be found
(C) in need of confirmation through comparison with an independent source of information about astronomical phenomena  Incorrect. The passage explicitly states that the hypothesis is untestable because of  the lack of an independent record of ice-age timing  
(D) incomplete and therefore  unusable  for the purposes of explaining the causes of ice ages
(E)  adequate enough for  scientists to support conclusively the idea that ice ages were caused by astronomical changes

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It's a great day to be alive!

SiffyB · Answer

Hi  SajjadAhmad ,

Could you please post the line numbers in the passage or highlight the part question 5 is referring to. I couldn't attempt this question because of the lack of clarity.

Thanks!

Palpable · Answer

Got all correct but took 16 mins

Posted from my mobile device

Eight times within the past million years, something in the Earth’s cl

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

Eight times within the past million years, something in the Earth’s cl

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards