mjoeb, I just came upon your posting. Your story certainly resonates with me as I too am preparing to write my GMAT for the 3rd time (got a 480 the first time (Jan 2008), 510 the second time (Nov 2008) and am aiming for a score of at least 550 to be considered for Rotman. I had the cold the second time so I had a difficult time thinking clearly. I'm nervous about not being able to reach at least the minimum GMAT requirement for Rotman. I'm thinking of calling the Admissions Director to get her feedback on my application and her thoughts on how much I need to increase my GMAT score by.
Now that a year has passed since your last posting, I'm curious to know if you reapplied to Rotman for 2008 and if you reached your desired GMAT score? You mentioned that the Admissions Director liked you, what was it about your application (resume, experiences, community work) that stood out to them? I'm hoping to learn from your experiences to help prepare my application.